Simonton Window Reviews

Home : Replacement Windows Reviews : Simonton

Simonton Windows And Doors

Simonton Windows And Doors is a relatively large manufacturer of vinyl windows and doors that are available in all 50 United States (via Home Depot), including Alaska and Hawaii. The company makes quality products (except for their entry level products) and stands behind their windows and doors with a double lifetime warranty. And while their lower end series like the Assure and 5050 series aren't great, their mid range and higher end Reflections, Impressions and StormBreaker Series are well built and often competitively priced. Scroll down to read all of our Simonton Windows reviews.

Overall Rating: Simonton Windows And Doors gets a 4.3 out of 5 stars based on 169 Simonton Windows reviews below.

My Take On This Company: Simonton is sometimes referred to as the Ford of the window industry - straight forward, well built, and not that glitzy. Overall, I think this is an apt description. However, their lower end vinyl windows and doors are best avoided in my opinion. Additionally, Simonton sells a slew of vinyl windows and doors (too many to keep it all straight). So stick to their better windows and doors and if you find a competitive price quote, then it ought to be a consideration for sure.
(Always Get 3 to 4 Local Price Quotes)

Dane - Site Editor - Original Publish Date - August 16, 2013
Page Last Update: December 13, 2025

Related Topic: Simonton Window Prices

Page Sections

• Window Series Introduction
• Simonton Windows And Doors
• Warranty Information
• Simonton Windows Complaints
• Simonton Daylight Max Reviews (Separate Webpage)
• Reflections 5050 Windows Reviews
• Simonton Asure Series Reviews
• Reflections 5300 Series Reviews
• Simonton Reflections 5500 Reviews (Separate Webpage)
• Impressions 9800 Series Review
• Simonton Madeira Reviews
• Simonton ProFinish Windows
• VantagePointe 6500 Windows Reviews (Separate Webpage)
• Simonton Generations Series
• Bay And Bow Window Reviews
• StormBreaker Plus
• Simonton Impact Windows Reviews
• Inovo Patio Door Reviews
• Slimline Series Reviews

Get Our Recommended Window List

Also please consider filling out the free form on our site for 3 quality window price quotes — it’s how we afford to provide free consumer information. We’re not incentivized by ANY company and will help you with ANY questions you might have, and help you navigate ANY bids you receive. That’s our guarantee to you!

Simonton Windows And Doors

As you can see from our Page Sections, Simonton sells a slew of vinyl windows and doors (or at least has since we started our Simonton Windows Reviews page back in 2013). Today, their most popular series include the VantagePointe 6500 Series (sold in Home Depots), their Reflections, Impressions, Daylight Max, and StormBreaker Plus impact window series.

Additionally, the company manufactures and markets certain vinyl window and patio doors for different parts of the United States (regionally based). Bearing that in mind, we have done our best to include all of the major series (three have their own pages to accomodate all of our consumer reviews). However, if you do have any questions on our Simonton windows reviews, please do not hesitate to email us using the link above.

"Simonton windows and doors are often said to be the Ford (as in Ford cars and trucks) of the window industry and it seems to be an apt description. They aren't the fanciest or best looking vinyl windows, but they are well made, sturdy and reliable. A solid buy at the right price point."

Simonton Window Warranty

Simonton sells lots of window and door series, so there is always going to be subtle differences between products. I’m going to detail the warranty on the Reflections 5500 series (arguably their most popular window series.) The company offers what they call a double lifetime limited lifetime warranty on the vinyl, hardware, components screen frame and glass. It includes a three year accidental glass breakage. The warranty does include any labor costs for the repair and/or replacement. (Labor warranties are always going to offered through the installation company as opposed to the manufacturer.) Scroll down to read all of our Simonton Windows reviews.

Top Of Page ˆ

Simonton Windows Complaints

The company sells A LOT of window and door series, which can be confusing. (It even confuses me sometimes and I live and breath this stuff.) Here is an example - the Reflections 5300 series is essentially identical to the Prism Ultra Gold Series (originally they teamed up with Norandex on this window). At one point, the Prism Series was only available to certain window dealers, but now the different names tend to be more geographical in nature.

Simonton Windows Reviews : 5050 Series

The 5050 series was one of the entry level models until they shifted to the Asure model. However, while the 5050 has been phased out in many sections of the country, it certainly crops up now and again. The Reflections 5050 uses a narrow profile, which allows more glass area, but sacrifices some energy efficiency and performance. The 5050 window is not the vinyl window I would recommend for most consumers.

Instead, I'd prefer they get the Simonton Impressions 9800 series or the higher end Reflections 5300 series. Of course, these windows are also going to be more expensive than the Simonton 5050 window. In general, it's probably fine for rentals or house flipping, but in terms of long term value, Simonton premium vinyl windows are going to serve most homeowners much better. Scroll down to read all of our Simonton Windows reviews on the 5050 Series.

Dane - Site Editor

Simonton 50 50 Windows vs 5500

Hi there, I'm having issues finding much good info on these, but I'm between:

- Simonton 5050

- Simonton 5500 (maybe? not sure how much more expensive)

- Ellison 1300 Series

- Atrium; similar model to the above

Would you know anything about these makes/models? Any help would be GREATLY appreciated, as there doesn't seem to be much helpful info out there that I can find + I can't get up with the companies themselves to save my life.

Thank you.

Kyle - Homeowner - from 2022

[Website Editor Reply]

Kyle, the Simonton 5500 series is the best of that bunch. I would go with that model over the 5050 series myself. Ellison windows are made by Atrium and I would say in general they are a step below the Simonton options.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2022

Simonton 5050 Windows Quotes

Good day Dane, I’m in the process of replacing the 24 windows on our house.

I have a $13K quote from a middle man that contracts different installer to measure and replace the windows with Simonton 5050 windows.

I got an $11K quote from an independent contractor that installs windows and doors also for the simonton 5050.

Fir tmrw I set up an appoint for another company to quote the replacement of all windows. They advertise replacing 8 windows from $3595. When I called them I ask for window brand, they use AMI. The company is window source of San Antonio. They have very good reviews online, but after reading some of ur responses, I don’t think I should use them bc of the AMI brand.

So my question, I want to hire the independent contractor but not comfortable with the skilled labor. He is a a constant battle with finding help to train. In these days many employers might have that problem. Is it best to high a middle man and not worry about the skill the install company brings. Or, go with the independent contractor and make sure he supervises each window installed?

Any input you have is greatly appreciated.

Edwin - Homeowner - from 2021

[Site Editor's Answer]

Hi Edwin, so AMI is pretty much a builder grade product and should probably be avoided if you are interested in maximizing your long term investment. The Simonton 5050 is more or less their entry level series and I would be a bit reticent about recommending this window either. Not necessarily a bad price on the Simonton 5050 though, so let's keep this in the hopper.

I would probably continue my search elsewhere, but you still might want to read our Simonton Windows reviews on the 5050 series. Having said that, here are my Texas-base recommendations:

[List Redacted -- contact us directly (Dane or Tim) for our Texas window recommendations.]

Dane - Site Editor - from 2021

Simonton 5050 Windows Reviews

Dane, I am looking to replace some wood windows with vinyl in my house. I got quotes for 4 windows that really need to be replaced and for all 13 windows. (4 - 36"x73" double hung, 3 - 36"x68" double hung, 2 - 36"x36" double hung, 1 - 48"x48" picture window, 1 - 48"x62" bay window, 2 - 38"x62" double hung on sides of bay windows)

I got three quotes for the windows
Zen Nirvana (Soft-Lite) :
3k for 4 windows
11k for all 13 windows (included tempered glass for bay and picture windows, excludes windows sills - additional ~400)

Simonton 5050:
3k for 4 windows
8k for all 13 for all windows (don't know that tempered was quoted but includes window sill replacement)

Okna (phone quote so not sure what style)
3-4k for 4 window
14-16k for all 13 windows

Do these quotes seem reasonable? Which option would you recommend? Also, is the Simonton 5050 still a base model vinyl? From your website it looked like they were not a quality vinyl but the person who gave me a quote said the only difference between Simonton 5500 and 5050 is that the 5500 has different options for colors and hardware.

Is that accurate or a cheesy sales pitch? Any help is very much appreciated! I got a lot of information from your website which is why I got quotes from the companies that I did. Thanks so much.

Lisa - Homeowner - from 2020

[Website Editor Reply]

Lisa, I think the bid prices are all in the normal bid range. The 5050 and 5500 are based on the same window frame. The 5500 has several nice upgrades that make the window a stronger version of the 5050.

I like the Zen Nirvana quote the best. The Soft-Lite Pro frame is better than the Reflections frame in my opinion. The other bid would be an upgraded bid to the Simonton 5500 model. It shouldn't be that much more than the 5050 and is a much better window.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2020

5050 Series vs PGT

Hi Dane, we are struggling with these two replacement window quotes and wonder if you can share your opinion?

PGT Energy Vue Windguard Series
4 single hungs: $4772
2 transom windows: $1437

5050 Series
4 openings: $2700
2 openings: $1450

Amy - Homeowner - from 2018

[Website Editor Reply]

Amy, I would need to know what window series Simonton is selling you. The PGT bid looks really high to me. $1400 for an impact window is very expensive.

Do you need impact windows? On our Simonton Windows reviews page, we list their Stormbreaker Plus impact window with reviews on the window.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2018

[Amy's Reply]

Hi Dane, thanks so much for your reply. I'm trying to find out the series. We don't need impact windows. To be honest, I'm leaning heavily toward the Simonton estimate as the installer comes highly recommended and I was very impressed with their presentation.

The PGT installer charges extra for permits and any stucco repair, while the Simonton guy says all that is included. Just found out it's Simonton Reflections 5050; spec-wise it's upgraded to the 5500.

Amy - Homeowner - from 2018

[Website Editor Reply]

Amy the 5500 series is a very solid window. I think the Simonton bid is absolutely the way to go. Best of luck on the project and let me know how it goes!

Dane - Website Editor - from 2018

Reflections 5050 Windows vs. PGT 5400

Greetings Dane and Tim,

First of all, thank you both so much for the invaluable contributions you guys are making for us confused consumers on your replacementwindowsreviews web site!

I have scoured through your web site trying to educate myself on the best mid-range vinyl window/door replacement choices in my area. Here is my project list –
3 - 96x80 sliding glass doors
1 - 62x80 french door

And the following windows, eight in total. I have received quotes for –

Simonton Reflections 5500 ($19,468 and $16950) -- from two different dealers
Simonton Reflections 5050 ($17,831)
Alside Mezzo ($14,429)
PGT 5400 series ($17850)
VyWinTech Shoreline ($17,501) ViWinTech Windows Reviews
Eagle View ($10,802)
MI ($14150) -- Not under consideration thanks to your advice!

From my quotes, it seems like the PGT windows are the most expensive, followed by Simonton, VyWinTech, and Alside Mezzo.

Eagle View is manufactured right here in Jacksonville and is direct from factory. Their quote does not include the French door since they don’t make French doors. They are a small company with only about 100 employees, so I would be concerned about the survivability of the company in the next recession.

But, their window sample seemed very heavy duty and well made, except for the plastic latch locks which I do not like. The salesman said it is a revival from the old Jordan window whose company went bankrupt back in the last recession.

I have only seen the PGT 5400, the Simonton 5500, and the Eagle View. Of those, I liked PGT the best, but they are the most expensive. I have not seen any questions on your site about VyWinTech or Eagle View windows. Do you have any thought on how these two would compare to the PGT 5400 series ?

Frank - Homeowner - from 2018

[Website Editor Reply]

Frank, you have lots of bids there, which is a great start. There are three that I like. The Simonton Reflections 5500 for $16950, the PGT 5400 series for $17850, and the Alside Mezzo for $14,429. I'd like to see you go with one of the first two, but at the price of the Mezzo :) Can you go back to these guys and see if they can match the Alside price? Here's an article that suggests an approach to this.

How To Negotiate With Window Salesmen

I like CWS so I'd keep that in the mix. If they did come in for a bid I would say that I had 8 bids already and I can't go over my budget of $16000 and see what they say. I don't know anything about Eagle View to say much. They have 22 reviews on google and they seem pretty solid. I'm worried that for the price their windows are another Alside Excalibur, poorly made. Having you looked at our Simonton Windows reviews page? Good place to start.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2018

Simonton 5050 vs. Vinylmax Edison 4600

I do not see an air filtration value for Vinylmax Edison. I live in Ohio and have all seasons but not as extreme as some states. I have no clue what value we need. Any info. on this? We were looking at double pane with Argon.

Also, my contractor (who uses Simonton but will do Edison if I prefer) says the Simonton 5050 and 5500 are energy star. I cannot see that the Edison has that rating unless I use triple pane. Is that correct?

Mary - Homeowner - from 2017

[Site Editor's Answer]

Mary, the Vinylmax company page has some great information on the window, including the Energy Star certification. An energy star symbol is a generic branding. Any window like the Vinylmax Edison that has better performance data will be Energy Star compliant. They offer a nice upgrade to the neopor insulation that I would seriously consider if it was my project (assuming my pocketbook could take the hit.)

The Vinylmax Edison 4600 double hung has a .12 air infiltration rating. A good number, not a great one, but quite solid. Vinylmax has a great data sheet for you and your contractor to look at. Have him provide you with a data sheet for the 5050 and then do an impartial analysis of the windows' performance.

The information I have on the Simonton 5050 is as follows: 5050 double hung has a .37 U-value, .45 VT and .21 air infiltration.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2017

Simonton Platinum Series vs. Pro Via Endure

Seems my parameters on price and value have me looking to choose one of these two. Pro via "endure" versus simonton " platinum." Which would you prefer? Installer will be the same. Thanks.

Ji - Homeowner - from 2017

[Site Editor's Answer]

Ji, I like both of these windows, but I would go with the ProVia Endure for sure. Very good air infiltration in the double hung at .05 and a design pressure of 50. Very solid window and better than the Simonton Platinum option in my opinion.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2017

Simonton Reflections 5050 vs PGT Energy View 5400

I am replacing my existing builder grade windows in my NW Florida home. I have hurricane storm shutters on my home so I am not in need of the impact resistance windows as a replacement. The two window models that I am comparing are the PGT Energy View 5400 and the Simonton Reflections 5050. The Cost proposals from two different companies are comparable so the question becomes which of the two is the better window? Interested in your thoughts. Thanks.

Scott - Homeowner - from 2016

[Site Editor's Answer]

Hi Scott, the PGT Energy View 5400 single hung is going to be the better window over the 5050, which is Simonton's entry level model in the Reflections series. I happen to think that PGT makes an excellent window for the price point. Make sure that the company who is installing the PGT has solid online or traditional reviews -- given this, I think PGT is the clear winner in terms of the window.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2016

All 5050 Series Simonton Windows reviews prior to 2015 have been archived for your convenience.

Top Of Page ˆ

Simonton Asure Windows Reviews

The Simonton Assure, introduced in spring 2012, is the redesigned Reflections 5050 window. The profile is even thinner, with nearly an inch of glass added to all four sides. The sash remains the same, although the frame has a cleaner, simpler look. The performance numbers didn't change much and you can upgrade to the Supercept if you're looking for a better spacer.

The Asure and 5050 share the same sash design, however many installers comment that they prefer the look of the newer Asure mainframe - innovation at work. The Asure window is not going to come in lots of options, tan or white exterior and interior color options and style choices that include a 2 lite slider, picture, double hung, and several geometric shapes. Comparable to Pella 250 window costs. Scroll down to read all of our Simonton Windows reviews on the Asure series.

Dane - Site Editor

Asure vs Norandex Perfexion

My contractor has suggested the Norandex Perfexion window, which he said is made by Simonton. Is this right? I thought Norandex was a separate company.

Manny - Homeowner - from 2018

[Website Editor Reply]

Manny, Simonton bought Norandex, or at least the Florida plant that makes the Perfexion line. The window is available in a number of different options, including the Silver, Gold and Platinum windows. I'd say the base Perfection window is on par with the Simonton Asure. I'd stick with the Gold or Platinum if I were you.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2018

Simonton Asure Windows

Replacing all windows in home, 13, enlarging 5. The contractor I am working with uses the Asure D-H windows. Consumer reports only rates the Simonton Pro-Finish Contractor window. We do not want to spend about $10,000 to replace our 1983 windows with cheap or cheap looking windows. Suggestions?

How do these compare? I have read through quite a few of the Simonton windows reviews you have posted, but I'm still not sure on this score. We live in Austin, TX. Also, which do you think is a better looking window, less bulky? Which would you recommend?

Arcelia - Homeowner - from 2017

[Site Editor's Answer]

I can't speak to the overall price he is quoting you out at, only because enlarging openings can be a costly business. The Simonton Asure double hung is an entry level vinyl window that you should insist your contractor NOT use. I would have him price out Don Young aluminum or vinyl windows, the Milgard Hermosa (a vinyl window made specifically for Texas), and the NT Presidential window.

If he insists on Simonton windows, I would suggest the Impressions 9800 series or the Reflections 5500 series. All of these window models should provide a good solid product at a price that shouldn't break the bank.

Dane - Site Editor - from 2017

Asure Window Review

Would you say the Simonton Asure line is a contractors / apartment grade? I am not finding many reviews on these windows.

Jordan - Homeowner - from 2015

[Site Editor's Response]

Jordan, the Simonton Asure is the entry level vinyl window that took over for the Simonton 5050 line back in 2012. The window is alright, it's actually one of the recommendations I make for "windows on a budget." It is very similar to the Simonton ProFinish Contractor, but with a nicer frame - the ProFinish is actually a new construction, while the Asure is a replacement window.

The short answer to your question is yes, the Asure is essentially a contractor grade window. However, with good installation it will work pretty well. If it were me, I would stretch for the Reflections 5300 or 5500 series - or the Impressions 9800 series, both from Simonton.

Dane - Site Editor - from 2015

Simonton Windows Reviews On The Asure

My husband and I are near Washington DC and we are trying to decide between Sunrise windows and Simonton Asure windows. All will be double-hung. Unfortunately, we can't get the extruded color we want from either of them. The windows on the back of our house are Andersen Renewal and they do have the right color, but we don't want to spend that kind of money again. What would you recommend if the prices end up close?

Janice - Homeowner - from 2015

[Site Editor's Response]

Janice, I am going to assume that you are looking at the entry level Sunrise Essentials, which would be the closest comparison to the Simonton Asure window. The standard Sunrise window and the upgraded models such as the Vanguard, Verde and Restorations are all a whole other level above the Asure model.

I'm not exactly sure which color you are looking for, but Okna is an excellent manufacturer that will be available in the Washington DC area and offers quite a few exterior color options, including brown, white, bronze, sandstone, cocoa, almond, and some other custom colors.

I believe that there are several local dealers who carries the okna brand and they can bring out window samples for you to take a look at, touch, feel, operate etc. In all likelihood, the local rep will just bring out a white as a sample, but they should have an Okna Delaer book that will show examples of the colors they carry. If that doesn't work out, let me know and I can help you further. This is where I'd start though.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2015

Simonton Asure Reflections Window

We are planning to replace three casement windows. Now the contractor propose the Simonton Reflection window. Is it the entry or mid level series?

Nancy - Homeowner - from 2015

[Site Editor's Response]

Nancy, the Simonton Reflections window is one of a number of "Collections" offered by Simonton and can be ordered in their entry level , mid range or high end model (each of which carries a Series number). The Simonton 5050 is the low end model, although this model is phased out in most areas and is now called the Asure. The mid range is the 5300 Reflections and is a decent mid range vinyl window.

The 5500 is an upgraded version of this, and has a slightly sturdier frame, a shadow grooved sash and I think a bit nicer looking. In general, Simonton manufactures good windows - not great - but very solid and honestly (assuming quality installation) is probably just fine for 80% of all households out there.

Bottom line, make sure you know which Reflections window you are buying and see if you can't see the actual window prior to purchasing so you can feel and touch it, check out the casement hardware, how it opens, etc. Assuming you like how it looks and feels, you should be in good hands. My only other suggestion is to take a look at our simonton windows reviews page and you should get a good understanding of the pros and cons on these.

Dane - Site Editor - from 2015

Top Of Page ˆ

Simonton Windows Reviews : Reflections 5300

The Simonton Reflections 5300 window, which is nearly identical to the Prism Platinum And Prism Gold Series, offers a better made and more durable mainframe over the Simonton Asure. The 5300 is a nice looking vinyl window, nothing fancy, and comes standard with some nice features, including the Intercept spacer, ProSolar low-e glass and a 3/4 inch insulating glass unit. Homeowners can order the 5300 Series in a double hung, fixed frame, slider, single casement, or in a double casement. Scroll down to read all of our Simonton Windows reviews on the 5300 series.

Dane - Site Editor

Simonton Gold Prism Series

Hi Dane. If I read the thread correctly, Simonton makes the Norandex Perfexion Platinum, Gold, & Silver series windows. I live in Kansas City, Missouri, & I am wanting to replace 9 windows with the Gold Series windows. Are the Gold Series good solid windows?

The company that I am getting the price on is, going to charge me $3900.00 for 9 windows installed. What's your opinion on this? Thank You.

Rickey - Homeowner - from 2018

[Website Editor Reply]

Rickey, you are correct in your Simonton models. The Gold is a good vinyl window, a very solid mid range window. $433 per window sounds like a very fair price to me. I'd still try to get them down to $400 a window for the Gold or see if they'll do the Platinum model for the $433 per window.

I think you're in the right price range and you have a good product. Now just see if they can sharpen their pencils a bit on that price. Let me know how it goes!

Dane - Website Editor - from 2018

Simonton Reflections 5300 Price Quote

Hi, can you give me a price on a Simonton Reflections 5300 double hung vinyl. 48 by 83 with 24 panes of glass? Looking to see cost of each window. Thanks.

Ronald - Homeowner - from 2017

[Site Editor's Answer]

Ronald, often there's a huge price variation in bids. I'm not sure I can give you a price on a window that size because you will probably have to put in two to three windows to cover the 7 feet across. Instead of getting a price from someone like me who hasn't seen the project firsthand and doesn't know what installation specifics are required, you need to go get a few free bids from local contractors.

This is the best way to get a sense of what the market rate is for your project specifics. The more bids you get, the better idea you will have of what brands are available in your area and what the overall price tag will be.

See if you can get the contractors and/or companies to break down the bids into product and labor. Feel free to send the bids/quotes my way once you get them and then I can give you my opinion on what the best bid is and can offer some tips on how to get the best price out of the bids you have!

Dane - Site Editor - from 2017

Simonton Reflections 5300 vs PGT 5400

I need 13 Windows. 7 are 36 x 62 ....6 are 36 x 70 trying to decide between PGT 5400 and Simonton Reflections 5300. Any help you can offer is welcomed, since the cost is upward of $10,000. Which brand would you suggest?

Lenny - Homeowner - from 2017

[Site Editor's Answer]

Lenny, both the PGT 5400 and the Simonton Reflections windows are good. I think I like the look of the PGT a bit better, but I think the numbers are going to be about the same -- not bad at all, but not great. What concerns me is the price for what are generally considered solid mid range vinyl windows. Obviously, I don't know anything about your installation needs so I can't speak to that, but you are paying $750 per window (assuming 13 windows at $10000). I'm not saying you are paying too much necessarily, but I think you need a couple more bids before you decide to go with either one of these -- and to see if these prices are too high.

I would try and find a Custom Window Systems or CWS rep in your area to give you a bid on whatever model they say is comparable to the 5400 PGT, perhaps the CWS 8000 model.

I would also check and see if perhaps there is a Zen Window in your area that could give you a bid on their Nirvana or Lotus model -- these are actually Soft-Lite Classic and Pro series windows. Try and see if any of these window brands are available as well -- Okna, Sunrise, Polaris and Soft-Lite.

For $750 per window, you should be able to get a top tier vinyl window, instead of a mid range vinyl. But again, every project is different so the additional bids should tune you into the fair market price.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2017

Prism Bronze vs Sunrise Restorations

Tim, I have 2 quotes on replacement windows.

1. Sunrise Restoration windows. 6 windows with grids. Size 35x59, with installation cost is $8322.

2. Prism Bronze by Simonton. 6 windows with grids $2974.

The one company only sells Restoration. I asked for middle of the road for the Simonton. The sample he brought said Prism Bronze on it but from what I can tell on your website, that is no longer being made.

Any opinions or suggestions that you can give me will be greatly appreciated.

Not sure where else to get estimates. We have Window World and Ideal Window companies here in Iowa but their windows are not that great.

Sharon - Homeowner - from 2016

[Site Editor's Response]

Sharon, the Restorations bid is so much more than the Prism Bronze. I would much prefer you get a quote on the Simonton Prism Platinum window over the Bronze, it is a much better window. I would imagine it would be somewhere in the $4000 to $4500 range (based on the Prism Bronze quote...) The Restorations is a great window, but I think you would be fine with the Prism Platinum.

Long story short, I think you need one or two more bids because you have two such different quality windows and bids in front of you. I would agree that you should bypass Window World, but I think Ideal makes a solid mid range vinyl window. I would absolutely get a bid from their local rep and see how their prices compare.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2016

All 5300 Series Simonton Windows reviews prior to 2015 have been archived for your convenience.

Top Of Page ˆ

Simonton Impressions 9800 Reviews

The Simonton Impressions 9800 is no longer being manufactured by the company. However, it was considered one of the company's best standard grade vinyl window series. It had similar performance numbers to the Reflections 5500 series, but many thought it was a better looking vinyl window, largely due to the different frame style and exterior color options.

When the Impressions 9800 model was first released, it was limited to a few dealers, but then anyone who offers Simontons can sell it. The original plastic handle on the sash had been replaced by two metal ones. It ran about $50 more than the 5500 Series and included the double lifetime warranty that still comes standard on many of the mid grade and higher end Simonton vinyl windows. Scroll down to read all of our Simonton Windows reviews on the Impressions 9800 series.

Dane - Site Editor

Simonton Impressions 9800 Vinyl Replacements

Hi Dane, I read your reviews of replacement windows and most of the better windows are sold in the East. I live in Colorado and I’m looking for a mid grade window, hopefully something comparable to the Okna 500 series. Do you have any recommendations?

Daniel - Homeowner - from 2021

[Site Editor's Answer]

Daniel, in Colorado you still have some nice options. Check if a Zen Windows services your area and that they have a good reputation. They do sell the Soft-Lite Pro, which they sell as the Zen Lotus or Zen Lotus Plus. Quite a solid window. Anlin is in Colorado and their Catalina or Del Mar are really nice. Amerimax is in Colorado and their Craftsman Portrait series are good. Finally, you should be able to find a Simonton dealer that sells the Reflections 5500 series or the Impressions 9800, both of which are quality mid range vinyl windows.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2021

Impressions 9800 Series In Arizona

Dane, again thank you for all of your advise. My contractor tells me that he can get Simonton (xo) (ox) and (oxxo). You earlier recommended that if I went with Simonton here in Arizona for my manufactured home I should get the higher end. What is the higher end for a Simonton window?

Judy - Homeowner - from 2021

[Site Editor's Answer]

Judy, I like the Simonton Reflections 5500 series and the Simonton Impressions 9800 series. Either of these is a solid model.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2021

Simonton 9800 In South Carolina

Hi, I really do not know which window to get. I have looked at our South Carolina manufacturers, Pellas, Lowes, but I am worried about making the wrong decision. It is very expensive. Please send any analysis you may have of good windows for a normal home in the hot South. Thank you.

Liz - Homeowner - from 2020

[Website Editor Reply]

Liz, windows I like include the Polaris ThermalWeld, Okna 500, Okna 400, Soft-Lite Classic and Pro, Kensington Huntington, Harvey Classic, Vytex Window Fortis Series, PGT 2300 and 5400, Simonton 9800 Impressions and Reflections 5500, Zen Nirvana and Lotus, Amerimax Craftsman Portrait, and Sunrise Classic. Check to see if SC window dealers carry any of these series.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2020

South Louisiana And Simonton Windows

Hi, we want to replace our 50 yr old single pane windows and would like to know what you suggest. We live in south Louisiana and it gets very hot and humid. Thank you!

Francis - Homeowner - from 2018

[Website Editor Reply]

Francis, I have to say that Louisiana is a tough state to make recommendations in. There used to be a Sunrise dealer out of New Orleans, but I can't seem to find him anymore. You may want to call up Sunrise and see if you can't find this out or not. That would be top on my list.

I would also check to see if there is a Simonton dealer near you. They have a number of solid series, including the Impressions 9800 and Reflections 5500, as well as the Simonton Daylight. This last model is available through Home Depot. I'm always a bit wary about recommending HD installation -- personally if I bought something from the big box stores I'd hire a local installer who had a great reputation.

Let me know if either one of these options works out. If not, recontact me and let's go from there. It may just take a bit of digging before we find a decent option for you.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2018

Simonton Windows Reviews 9800 Elite Plus

Tim I just met with an affable guy from 1st Choice a small local outfit-Denver area. As my windows get baked with morning sun he strongly suggested triple pane. Simonton 9800 Elite Plus or Sunrise Restoration. There is nothing special about the installation. $3572 for Simonton, $3929 for Restoration. Those seem like a nice step up from the Zen Nirvana for not much more. Friday I meet with someone from Colorado Classic, who also does Soft Lite.

The Restoration doesn't have argon gas, the Simonton does. He seemed to think that argon wasn't necessary on a triple pane, implying they will eventually leak anyway. Any thoughts?

I am not concerned about the absolute best price so much as a fair price with excellent service.

Too many bids will only confuse this old guy. I really appreciate your site and you getting back to me.

Regards.

Lew - Homeowner - from 2018

[Website Editor Reply]

Lew, both the Simonton 9800 Elite Plus and Sunrise Restoration are great choices, but the Sunrise Restoration is the winner between these two and is worth the extra money. In fact, it's one of the best vinyl windows out there and in my top three, an excellent performer.

You may want to ask him if he can do the Sunrise at the Simonton price and see what he says. Depending on how much work he has, he may drop the price a bit.

Good luck and let me know how it goes!

Tim - Site Editor - from 2018

Simonton 9800 vs Sunrise Verde

Hi there, I am looking to slowly replace all the windows in our home (built in 1995) in Colorado. The major concern is noise and heat/cool transfer. The sun is pretty intense on a couple of the west facing windows. I got a quote from a local company who installs Sunrise Verde windows for around $950 a window and a larger company who does Simonton 9800 for around $1350/window.

Of course they both say their window is the best. Simonton's windows are triple pained- I'm wondering if that is better or unnecessary? We can hear a decent bit of car noise currently through the windows with a somewhat large street outside. I'm leaning towards Sunrise Verde because I liked the company and price tag better (my husband is worried about going with the lower bid) but is their a big difference between the windows? I don't want to regret a window purchase and are open to either, just want to know which one is the best choice! Thanks for your input!

Joy - Homeowner - from 2018

[Website Editor Reply]

Joy, both of these windows are good, but I'm happy to tell you that I would say the Sunrise Verde is better than the Simonton 9800 model. Sunrise makes a great window and the Verde model is one of their best. The Simonton 9800 model is their best window, but I don't think its air infiltration, fit, and tolerances can match the Verde.

That's quite a high per window price -- I'm assuming the installation is tricky in some way. You might want to grab a couple more bids from local companies just to make sure that that's the fair market price.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2018

[Joys Reply]

Thanks so much for your advice. I’ve been trying to figure out which ones are better and of course since they both claim to be the best it’s impossible! Stressful. Well I got 3 quotes- Andersen ($5000 for 2 windows!), a local company (who installs verde windows) and a larger Colorado company with Simonton. Maybe since we live in Boulder, Co the price/cost of living is higher?? Also they are rather large windows- 2 large sliding windows and upstairs so that may be harder?

Thanks Dane!

Joy - Homeowner - from 2018

[Website Editor Reply]

Joy, it sounds like the Andersen is not the way to go based on the price :) At the end of the day, pricing is based on the project and it sounds like you have the range of prices. On the plus side, you have a great window in the Verde and they gave you the best price. I think you've got your answer! Thanks for taking a look at our Simonton windows reviews page and I am glad everything worked out.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2018

Simonton 9800 vs CWS 610/615 vs PGT EnergyVue

I live in the Orlando area I have narrowed my search to the final three. I believe that I’ve negotiated the best possible price and wanted your opinion. The Simonton has the best warranty but I’m more concerned about the quality of the product and appearance and not the warranty (since all three have a good warranty). Thanks in advance for your assistance.

$11,500.00 Simonton 9800

$11,268.00 CWS 610/615

$10,175.00 PGT 5400 EnergyVue

I have the following size windows: 2 each 36 x 49 ½ picture window, 1 each 82 x 105 Picture Window, 1 each 72 x 24 x 12 Eyebrow & Legs Picture, 1 each 36 x 24 picture window, 1 each 96 x 19 picture window, 1 each 36 x 61 hung window, 3 each 30 x 36 picture window, 3 each 52 x 70 hung window, 1 each 36 x 24 hung window

Meredith - Homeowner - from 2018

[Website Editor Reply]

Meredith, I like all three bids and windows you have and good work on getting the bids as low as you can get. I would say the PGT is the winner for me given the product and the price. Assuming you are comfortable with the company doing the work, I think you have found a good option. My second choice is the Simonton 9800.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2018

Simonton Impressions 9800 Series

Dane, Florida building code was changed in 2015 and pretty much requires vinyl windows be used to meet the energy efficiency. I am concerned about the long term durability of using vinyl in such a high temperature and high UV environment. I am considering the Simonton Impressions 9800 series as a replacement for 14 Windows. Several of the Windows on on the southern side of the house get direct sunshine most of the day.

I have seen many articles not recommending vinyl Windows in such an environment so am confused as to why the Florida building code now recommends them for efficiency. Some companies won't even offer aluminum framed Windows because of the efficiency requirement in the code. What are your thoughts?

John - Homeowner - from 2017

[Site Editor's Answer]

John, vinyl windows are the most energy efficient on the market (fiberglass is very close behind). Aluminum is very bad in terms of energy efficiency, even the thermally broken options now available.

The articles not recommending vinyl windows either were written back when the industry did have problems with vinyl warping under intense heat, or are from people who advocate another material because they rely on that material for their livelihood. I will also say this, poorly made vinyl windows are still subject to long term issues with the vinyl warping, although this now tends to be with wide windows that can't support the weight across the span.

Well made vinyl windows are much better equipped to handle heat, salt and humidity than any other material with the exception of aluminum. Aluminum is incredibly strong, much stronger than vinyl, but the performance data on them is so bad that it makes no sense to use them.

The Simonton Impressions 9800 is the company's best series in my opinion and quite a good window. It should have no problem holding up to the weather in Florida. It does carry a lifetime warranty in case something does go wrong. As always, make sure to stay in touch with whomever installs the window just in case you need them down the road.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2017

Simonton Impressions vs. Milgard Tuscany

Hi, I stumbled on your Simonton windows reviews page and am searching for a good replacement window for the hot Arizona climate. I want something that is energy efficient but not too bulky because I want to be able to install flush mounted shutters after the windows are installed. What would you recommend in a low to mid price range? Vinyl or aluminum?

Mary Jo - Homeowner - from 2017

[Site Editor's Answer]

Mary Jo, first off I would say don't get a low end vinyl window, not in the hot Arizona sun, this will likely cost you more money in the long run. A mid range vinyl window should suffice.

I would recommend you get a bid from a local company that sells the Milgard Tuscany model. Ask them if they sell aluminum as well and if so have them bring a sample for you to pick up etc. and get a price on both of those.

Anlin services Arizona and is a good brand. They offer several nice models.

Amerimax also should have local reps and I would get a bid from them.

Finally, find a Simonton dealer who sells the Impressions Series and/or the Restorations Series. These are the two series that I like from Simonton.

Explain to the reps that you want to flush mount your blinds and assuming you know the dimensions, have them show you with a tap measure how deep the vinyl windows will sit and whether that will leave enough room for the blinds. Do this with each of the companies that comes out. By the third bid you will have a good idea whether this is going to work or not.

Remember that bulky and energy efficient stand in direct contrast -- a bulky vinyl frame typically offers good performance, while a thin frame will usually sacrifice some performance.

Dane - Site Editor - from 2017

Simoton 9800 vs. Alside Mezzo

Tim, I found your site through googling Simonton Windows Reviews and I'm hoping you can help. We have quotes for both of these windows with a big price difference. Are we trying to compare apples to oranges? Would you recommend the Alside Mezzo over the Alside Sheffield? Our quote for those are about the same. Will appreciate your assessment.

Mark - Homeowner - from 2016

[Site Editor's Response]

Mark, there is a big difference between the Simonton 9800 series and the Alside Mezzo. The 9800 is one of the best window series from Simonton and I would say the Mezzo is just an okay vinyl window, maybe in the lower end of the mid range. I would say the Alside Mezzo is better than the Sheffield, so if the option is between these two, I would go with the Mezzo. In general, Simonton windows are one tier up from Alside, although the Ultramaxx from Alside is a pretty decent window.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2016

Simonton 9800 vs PGT 5400 Window

Trying to choose between Simonton 9800 and PGT 5400 EnergyVue. The warranty is better with simonton and cost is about the same. Which is more energy efficient in Florida?

Ken - Homeowner - from 2016

[Site Editor's Response]

Sorry for the delay in getting back to you Ken. I like both these windows. The Impressions 9800 is Simonton's best window IMO, very solid. I happen to really like the PGT 5400 single hung and think it's an excellent choice at the price point. If it were me, I'd go with the PGT option. This is assuming equal quality installation. This is the factor I would use to make the decision more than the window itself. Installation is going to be half of the equation so if the windows are roughly the same, that should really be the deciding factor.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2016

Simonton Impressions vs Renewal by Andersen

Tim, My apologies if this has been asked and reviewed already. If that's the case, you may just direct me to the previous review. We are looking at replacing 7 "normal" sized double-hung windows and three sliding windows of various sizes. We've had a local contractor come look at the job, and he uses Simonton vinyl windows...the model i am not sure of yet.

Based on some other estimates he had in his book, I'm guessing his quote will be in the $6,000 - $9,000 range. We will have the quote this week. He has a well-established company that isn't huge, but isn't tiny either. We also had an estimate from Renewal by Andersen for the same job and it came to $24,000. Their big pitch was their Fibrex composite material for durability/strength/etc.

Is this Fibrex material really that good and is it enough to warrant 3 times the cost versus a quality vinyl window? We live in St. Louis, so the weather conditions can vary quite a bit; high heat, humidity, high winds, storms. Our winters aren't too bad, but can get down in the teens a few times.

Hans - Homeowner - from 2016

[Site Editor's Response]

Hans, the Renewal Cost Quote is pretty typical and is not something that I would ever consider for my own home (one, I couldn't afford it and two it isn't worth it, although they do make nice windows, just not worth the crazy price tag). So if it were me, I would throw out the RBA at the outset.

Simonton makes a good vinyl window, but they are nowhere near the best. Their Impression 9800 series is the one window that I would say is quite good. I'd like to see you get a quote on some other windows, I know Zen has a branch in St. Louis - they sell Soft-Lite windows under a different name. Sunrise may be available in St. Louis, as well as Okna. Try these window brands and see how their mid range to slightly better vinyl windows compare in price to the quote you got for the Simonton. These are going to be higher quality vinyl windows and will provide you with the best long term value (although they will be more expensive at the outset).

Tim - Site Editor - from 2016

Please note that all Impressions 9800 Simonton Windows reviews prior to 2015 have been archived.

Top Of Page ˆ

Simonton Windows Reviews : Madeira Series

Scroll down to read all of our Simonton Windows reviews on the Madeira series.

Madeira Window vs Anlin Catalina

The Catalina is a very good window as well. The Simonton Madeira and Daylight are a step below this but still good windows. The Milgard Intrinsic is right on par with the Simonton offerings. Just make sure to find a well reviewed online company to do the work.

Ellen - Homeowner - from 2021

[Site Editor's Answer]

Thank you so much have bid on anlin but is Catalina is Catalina. Also working with.another company these not on your list Simonton maderia and daylight max should I push for ones on your list. Or are thes ok also Milgard intrinsic. Same not on your list. Phone bids work or have to come to come to.condo have 3 anlin quotes.

Dane - Site Editor - from 2021

Simonton Madeira vs Milgard

Hi Dane and/or Tim. I really appreciate your site. It's one of the few places I've found to get some good information on replacement Windows. I've been researching replacement windows for about 6 weeks now and feel no closer to making a decision than before.

Puget Sound/Seattle area home
Need new windows to improve comfort (25 windows)
Simonton Madeira$1,400/window for
Ply Gem 2Quoted $1,200/window for
Insignia e2 Quoted $800/window for (aka AMI casement window with upgrades)
Revere Berkshire EliteQuoted $500/window for (same AMI casement without upgrades)
Almost decided on Milgard Tuscany windows but had a low quality feeling when testing
Alside has had a bad rap in the past but the Insignia the salesperson brought seemed like a nice hefty window
Not sure what to do now, curious abut Champion but unsure if it's worth the time

The Full Story

My family and I moved into a 1983 two story home last September. After a very drafty winter we are looking for ways to improve comfort in our home. We already have plans to foam insulate under the floor which has many bats of fiberglass insulation falling down and we are going to do some work in the attic. There's no getting around it however, our old aluminum windows, despite being double pain are incredibly chill inducing.

Dennis - Homeowner - from 2018

[Website Editor Reply]

Wow, $1400 per window for a Simonton Madeira, that is quite a hail mary on the salesperson's part. I think if you look at our Simonton windows reviews or pricing page, you will see this is way more than I would advise. I'm glad you didn't go with that. Typically on the West Coast, I recommend three brands: Milgard, Anlin and Amerimax, but Anlin isn't available in Washington. It sounds like you didn't like the look and feel of the Tuscany, which is the window I often recommend. I'll admit it isn't the best window out there, but it's a decent middle of the road vinyl window in my opinion. But if you didn't like it, don't put it in your house.

I'm not a huge fan of Alside or AMI so I have a hard time recommending either of these.

If you are getting a bid of $600 to $800 for Milgard Tuscany, then your project must be a bit more complicated than your typical one.

Champion makes a good vinyl window. Tell them that you already have four bids and you want them to come out, measure, and give you their best bid. Tell them you don't have time to sit around and listen to some spiel, you just want their best bid.

Can you get a bid for Amerimax and see if they are available in your zip code?

What about taking a look at the Andersen 100 at a Home Depot and finding a good local installer?

Maybe a quote from Marvin on their Integrity or Infinity, but they might be quite pricey.

This is a tricky one...I'd keep getting bids and be honest with them that you have a bunch of bids and need a good vinyl window in the $500 to $660 range.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2018

Simonton Madeira vs Milgard Tuscany Doors

Hello Tim and Dane, I was googling window/door brands that were quoted to me and found your site. There was a Q&A I read about several brands, but I did not see a discussion on the Simonton Madeira vs Milgard Tuscany. Two contractors quoted me closely on these two, and I just want to know which one you would recommend. The Simonton Madeira quote was about $100 more than the Milgard Tuscany quote, so it really just boils down to door quality etc, and not price anymore.

My house faces the west and gets a lot of sun. We also had a problem with a leak with our current french doors which is why I thought about changing to sliding doors since I had to address the problem anyway. I hope you can help. Thank you, Maica.

Maica - Homeowner - from 2016

[Site Editor's Response]

Hi Maica, the Madeira and the Tuscany are close in quality, I might give the nudge to the Milgard Tuscany, more out of Milgard's reputation than anything else. Typically, Milgard is going to be more expensive than a comparable Simonton so that one more reason to go Milgard. Sliding doors are quite energy efficient and I know a number of people who have switched from the French Doors to a slider (especially if French Door design is just not your thing.)

I like Milgard products, I tend to recommend them quite a bit. Good luck and let me know how it all works out!

Tim - Site Editor - from 2016

Maica's Response

Thank you so much, Tim! It was hard to decide at first because both installers were responsive. Simonton installer had more positive reviews on Yelp but the Milgard installer is diamond certified (not sure how much weight that carries though). With your advice, the price, and the brand all aligning, I will go with Milgard.

Really appreciate your quick response and advice!

Maica - Homeowner - from 2016

Please note that all Madeira Simonton Windows reviews prior to 2015 have been archived.

Top Of Page ˆ

Simonton ProFinish Windows Reviews

The Pro-Finish series gets quite a bit of attention thanks to its inclusion on the 2014 Consumer Reports Best Replacement Windows where the Contractor model ranked well in the vinyl window category. The Pro Finish comes in 3 models or options, The Builder, The Contractor and The Master. Each of these model options comes as a new construction window, which means that a nailing flange or fin is included across the top and two sides for easier and more secure installation.

The Simonton ProFinish Builder model is just as the title indicates; a builder grade window that is bare bones and does not offer the sort of performance or components that are going to offer any long term value. The Contractor model is pretty close in construction and quality to the Simonton Asure window (see above). The one difference between these two is the slightly inferior balance system used by the ProFinish model. The Master model includes a few nice upgrades, including a better sash design that is very similar to the one used by the Reflections 5500 model. The Master uses a solid masterframe and should achieve a DP35, a pretty standard number in the window industry. Scroll down to read all of our Simonton Windows reviews on the Simonton ProFinish Series.

Dane - Site Editor

Simonton Pro Finish Questions

Thanks, Dane! I got a few quotes. We're going to go with Simonton.

First, for the replacements: I got a quote from Home Depot. For a 32" x 71" double-hung with tempered glass on the bottom sash and 6 lite grill pattern on the top sash only, they quoted me $379 without tax. In terms of the window series, all it says is "Pro". I asked them what series number that is and they said they didn't know. Do you know if the "Pro" is the same as the 5500 or 5050 series? 

At a local building supply store that sells Simonton, they quoted me $420 without tax for a 5050 Simonton with the same specs as above. They also sell the 5500 Simonton, but the dealer said he sells a lot more of the 5050s, so that is what he recommended. Any thoughts? Is it worth the extra cost for the 5500?

Second, for the new constructions windows: For a 36" x 60" double-hung with tempered glass on the bottom sash and 6 lite grill pattern on the top sash, Home Depot quoted me $419 without tax. In terms of the window series, all it says is "Contractor". I don't know what that means and how it compares to the new construction options listed on the Simonton website. Do you know?

The local building supply store quoted me $450 without tax for the ProFinish Contractor. The number "3050" is also listed in the quote, which may or may not be useful info for identifying the series. 

Any thoughts or suggestions on how we should proceed?

Thanks!

Doug - Homeowner - from 2022

[Website Editor Reply]

Doug, Simonton has so many models that are sold in so many different places -- it's hard to keep up. My understanding is that Home Depot only sold the VantagePointe 6000 series, but perhaps that has changed.

I think it is definitely worth it to upgrade from the 5050 to the 5500 series myself. Most people buying direct from local building supply stores are looking for the least expensive model, but not the best quality for their money. Long term I think there is real value in that upgrade.

I'm beginning to think that they are selling the Simonton ProFinish model -- which might explain the Pro part.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2022

ProFinish Brick Mold

Dane good afternoon. I review the window specs for a potential home I would like to build. The spec calls for Simonton pro finish brick mold or the ViWinco (no model description) both will have high performance low e 4.

I would appreciate it if you can provide any insight to these window. Thank you.

Joe - Homeowner - from 2022

[Website Editor Reply]

Joe, I would go with the Simonton over a ViWinco window myself. The ProFinish is a decent window and comes in 3 models or options, The Builder, The Contractor and The Master. Each of these model options comes as a new construction window. Additionally, check out our Simonton Windows reviews page to read up on the ProFinish, which is available in three different product levels.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2022

Simonton ProFinish Bulder Grade Quote

Hi Dane, we asked the contractor that had bid the Viwinco to bid an alternative product and he came back with a Simonton profinish builder grade. From what I have seen on your site that isn’t an impressive product. I am going to see if he could bid the Simonton reflections 5500.

The other contractor who had bid the Marvin windows also has Provia available. I am hopeful that he will bid the Endure series. Of the two could you please comment on which is the better window?

I might add that we are replacing 17 windows on an atrium wall. Some of the windows are extremely large with the biggest being a pentagon shape at the top. That window and the two immediately below it are roughly 6‘ x 6‘ (with the top window having the Pentagon point on top, all one piece of glass). So, I want to ensure we get a strong window.

Thank you again for your response! It is so helpful to have someone knowledgeable!

Lynne - Homeowner - from 2020

[Website Editor Reply]

Lynne, I would say the Simonton Reflections 5500 is equal to the Provia Aspect. The Provia Endure however is their premium window and a very good option. The Simonton ProFinish Master model is a pretty darn good window. The ProFinish comes as the Builder, Contractor, and Master series. Definitely get a quote on the Provia Endure and see how that compares to your others!

My issue with your project has always been timeline. I just wouldn't be keen on spending lots of money on windows if you are moving in 5 years...

Dane - Website Editor - from 2020

Simonton ProFinish Brickmould 600

Hello, we are comparing the Paradigm 8300 vs. the Simonton Brickmould 600. Do you have a recommendation for the suburban Philadelphia area?

Siding will be done at the same time, which should help with options.

Thank you.

Laurie - Homeowner - from 2020

[Website Editor Reply]

Laurie, the Paradigm 8300 is a decent mid range winow. The Simonton Brickmould 600 is the better window, but not by a ton. Your pricing sounds about right. These are however considered decent windows, but not great windows. For me, I do like the Simonton brand as a nice mid range window. With competent installation, their windows solid.

Are there better options, yes. I will send you a list.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2020

[Laurie's Reply]

Dane - You are awesome!!!! I didn’t really know if I would get a response to this e-mail. Thank you so very much. You are so kind!

I’ll investigate based on your e-mail below, and let you know what I find.

Laurie - Homeowner - from 2020

Simonton Windows Reviews Pro Finish Contractor

I am looking for replacement windows without the tint of the low e glass. A salesman says he can get me Simonton Reflections 5500 without the low e, but it is also without argon gas. This window is not rated on Consumer Reports, but the Simonton Pro - Finish Contractor is rated 83.

A sales person from Pella suggested the 250 with natural sun glass. This window has only a 62 rating on Consumer Reports. I am also worried about it having a tint.

Each person showed me only one model. I am confused and wonder if I should look further. I would like to get a window with argon gas but no low e. Any ideas? I expect to spend from $8-12,000.

Nancy - Homeowner - from 2018

[Website Editor Reply]

Nancy, the Simonton Reflections 5500 is the best window of the bunch you mentioned. It isn't rated because Consumer Reports only has access to retail windows, which most quality windows are not. Most quality windows are only sold through dealers. The Reflections 5500 is one of the best windows that Simonton sells and is a solid vinyl window.

The argon gas fills are not a big deal, they will make the window 10% more efficient, which isn't that impressive. Typically, either a window comes in a low-e with a fill or in clear glass without. That's just how it works. If you don't want the low-e, stick with the best window you can find.

The Simonton ProFinish Contractor is a decent window, but the Reflections is better in my opinion.

In general, I'm not a big fan of the Pella 250 and I think the CR rating bears this out.

Should you look further, sure, it can't hurt to get a few more bids. They're free and they help educate and inform, which can only help you make the best decision possible. You may find a company that offers exactly what you're looking for.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2018

Simonton Pro-finish Contractor Series

Hi, thank you for all of the information you provide on your website. We’re building a new custom home in Northern Virginia and I need advice on vinyl window options:

Our contract specifies Simonton Reflections 5500 series or equivalent windows. Our contractor said that model is a replacement window and proposed 3 other windows: Jeld-Wen Builders Vinyl, Andersen Silverline series, or MI Windows 1556 series. After researching these windows, I don’t think these are equivalent, but rather lower level/quality windows.

Do you have recommendations for budget-friendly new construction vinyl windows? I read the reviews/information on Simonton Pro-finish Contractor series – would that be equivalent to the Reflections 5500 series? We’re not looking for high end, but we want something above builder grade that’s good quality and is going to last.

Stacey - Homeowner - from 2018

[Website Editor Reply]

Stacey, all three of the windows you mentioned are not high quality windows in my opinion. I think the Simonton ProFinish Master would be equivalent to the 5500. The ProFinish comes in the Contractor and Builder -- so not the Builder, maybe the Contractor

Also perhaps look at the Ply Gem Mira double hung window.

Can your contractor get pricing on the Okna 600 Eco Pro?

What about a Sunrise window?

These would be my suggestions.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2018

Simonton ProFinish vs. Okna 400

Hello -- you Simonton Windows Reviews have been super helpful! I have extensively researched replacements for 10 sliding windows and 3 6’ and 2 8’ sliding patio doors. Would you be able to offer an opinion on my options?

Currently considering:

Simonton ProFinish Doors
Sunrise (models above Essentials) windows

OR

Okna 400 windows
SoftLite Doors

Neither of the contractors that I like recommend the doors that match the windows so I either go fully with Simonton or mix and match. I am disinclined to use Simonton for both windows and doors.

Here is my criteria:

Maximum glass
Ease of use for doors, especially for the 8’ ones
Style to match contemporary house
Ability to have white on interior and brown tone on exterior

Also, one of the contractors has said I need to be careful about the glass used as some brands are dark. He specifically mentioned Guardian.

This has been mind boggling as I want to make a good decision. Both contractors are well recommended though I prefer the contractor who uses Simonton and Sunrise.

Thank you for your help!

Nanette - Homeowner - from 2018

[Website Editor Reply]

Nanette, I like both of the options in a broad sense so that's a good start. In terms of brands alone, I would have to lean towards the Okna/Soft-Lite. Simonton is a good manufacturer, but not quite in the same league as the other three. Having said that, each manufacturer has a number of series and that has a lot to do with the quality of product you are getting. The Simonton ProFinish for instance has three grades itself so make sure you avoid that Builder model and stick with the Contractor or Master options. However, even the Okna 400 is probably as good as the top of the line from Simonton.

Simonton tends to have less glass area than other window brands, including Okna and Soft-Lite. In terms of windows, the Sunrise Restorations is one of the narrowest frames without sacrificing on performance and strength.

I would say two things: one, make sure you are able to look at the products you are buying to see how the hardware looks, how thick the frames are, how the windows and doors open and close. Hopefully there is a showroom close or the contractor has samples of the windows and/or doors to show you.

Assuming you like the look and function, I would go with the contractor you feel most comfortable with and the one who will do the best job. Bad installation issues after the fact is a much bigger deal than the small differences between the products that you won't notice once they are in your home.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2018

Simonton ProFinish Contractor vs Wincore 7700 Series

Tim, We are looking to replace all windows in our 35 year-old home. Our contractor is a Simonton Contractor. We would use 5 picture windows, 4 sliders, 3 single or double hung, and enlarging the kitchen window to as big as possible. We live in Austin, TX.

Questions regarding your Simonton Windows reviews page:

1) Do you recommend Simonton windows? If so, which model would be a mid-range to mid-range+ and, if you had to guess, how much might we expect to pay?

2) What do you think of the Simonton Pro-Contractor replacement windows? Where do these fall in terms of quality, look, and price relative to other common windows?

3) What do you think of the Wincore Windows 7700 Series? How to the Simonton windows you recommend compare to these?

4) If we were going to enlarge our dining room window as much as possible, like a wall or 3/5 of a wall, what brand, make and model would you recommend?

5) How do we verify if a contractor is competent and reasonable and knows what they are doing?

6) How much quieter will 3-pane windows be relative to 2-pane windows?

I know this is a lot. I appreciate any information you may be able to share with us and/or any advice you may be able to provide.

Arcelia- Homeowner - from 2017

[Site Editor's Answer]

Arcelia, Simonton windows are generally considered a solid manufacturer, nothing special in terms of looks or overall quality, but a decent mid range manufacturer. I always say they are like the "Ford" motor company of windows. Like Ford, they make a number of windows and I would put the ProFinish Contractor in the low-mid of range vinyl window quality. (I'm assuming this is the model you are talking about, although you didn't mention the ProFinish part anywhere in your email)

The ProFinish comes in three models itself; the Builder, Contractor and the Master. The Contractor is a very similar window to the Simonton Asure series. I think if it were me, I would feel more comfortable pressing him to price out the ProFinish Master window. I feel like the Master model offers some nicer standard features and would provide some more durability and performance over the Contractor model.

Wincore makes two models, the 5400 and the 7700. I definitely like the 7700 model over the 5400. I like this window and this manufacturer, perhaps a bit more than Simonton, but only because they are smaller and offer a little more of a personal touch over Simonton, which is the largest window manufacturer in the United States. Pros and cons to both. I think I would give the edge to the Wincore 7700 series over the Simonton ProFinish Master, but I'd have to look at the following performance data before I stuck to my own opinion:

Design Pressure
Air Infiltration
U-factor
Condensation Resistance

I would stick with the same brand of window for the whole project for the sake of continuity, although if the opening is too wide across, you may have to use an aluminum clad window to support the weight across the span. This is where a good contractor comes in.

Triple pane windows will help some with the performance such as U-factor and could have an impact on sound reduction. The biggest issue with sound attenuation is the distance or space between the panes (different glass thicknesses as well but typically triple pane glass is the exact same thickness and this doesn't help much). If the triple pane option uses a deeper of thicker window frame and therefore provide more space between pane 1 and 3, then there will be some nice noise reduction. If the depth of the window frame between pane 1 and 3 is unchanged (i.e. the manufacturer basically slides one more pane between the standard pane1 pane2, then the only change would be the glass, so therefore not a ton, but a bit).

Verifying a good contractor for me begins with rock solid references. If they have worked with homes in the community, get several referrals and call up the homeowners and ask about the experience overall, the work, how it's held up, any financial problems that arose. Then check with the BBB website, look for online or social reviews of the company, check out our Simonton Windows reviews page, and make sure they are licensed and bonded.

Finally, structure the contract so that payments are made at different portions of the project, 1/3 up front, 1/3 at the half completion mark, and 1/3 at the completion mark. Also insist that there is a labor warranty guarantee in case anything goes wrong in the 1st or 2nd year.

After this, there isn't much more you can do but just stay vigilant yourself as the project goes along, each day check the work, and look for anything that doesn't seem right. If it doesn't speak up -- contractors and workers tend to do a better job if the homeowner is looking at details because they know they'll have to go back and do it over if they screw up.

Dane - Site Editor - from 2017

Simonton Contractor vs. Jeld-Wen Siteline Auralast

Hi, I am getting ready to replace 20 windows. I have an assortment, including some picture windows, one slider, and several casement windows. My contractor is offering me the Simonton Contractor Single-hung Series. When looking at the Simonton website, I can't figure out what level of windows we are talking about. He says they are all pretty much the same except for options offered, such as hardware finishes and outside or inside color finishes.

I don't want cheap looking windows. We replaced 9 windows last year, and used Jeld-Wen Siteline Auralast windows ( wood inside with aluminum clad exterior).They are very nice, and look like quality windows, but obviously the price difference is huge (2x). Will I be getting good quality windows if I go with my contractors proposal?

Thank you. Very much appreciate your time and look forward to your response.

Mayra - Homeowner - from 2017

[Site Editor's Answer]

Mayra, I'm assuming that your contractor is offering the Simonton Pro-finish Contractor Series in a single hung. They is in the middle of what Simonton sells -- I think that's fair to say. The Pro-finish (and again I'm speculating that this is what he is talking about) is available in three models; the Builder, the Contractor, and the Master. Consumer Reports gives the Contractor Model a good grade, but I personally have some issues about how they test windows.

The Pro-finish also comes in the Master, which I believe is the better window and shouldn't run too much more, 20% more perhaps. If he has access to the Master model, this is the model that I would inquire about.

I would say that the Pro-finish Contractor is a mid range window and the Master is a decent window. I also like the Jeld-Wen Auralast window, which is a bit of a rarity since there aren't many wood windows that I recommend for the overall longevity of the product. The Auralast process seems to be a good one -- although time will tell if the windows last as long as their warranty says they will.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2017

Simonton ProFinish Windows

I recently purchased a Mobile Home built in 1989 and would like to replace nine existing windows with mid range energy efficient single hung windows. Should I be looking for a certain type, Frame & manufacturer. Are there makes of windows that are more designed for Mobile Homes? I have received one estimate from a contractor for installing (single hung profinish builder white single hung windows J channel. Would these be Simonton low end windows? Any advice on purchasing new windows for my Mobile home would be greatly appreciated!

Pamela - Homeowner - from 2016

[Site Editor's Response]

Pamela, I don't think there are any specific windows for mobile homes, the biggest issue will be the frame depth and how the replacement window fits into the opening. The Simonton ProFinish model comes in three options, the Builder, Contractor and Master. The Builder is the entry level and I wouldn't recommend that one. I think the Contractor and Master would fit with what you are looking for. I also like the premium Reliabilt 3500 and 3900 series, the Sunrise Essentials or preferably the standard Sunrise series, and the Ply Gem Pro series.

Some of these options should be available in your area and you should have the companies come out and provide you with a bid so you can get pricing and also to be able to handle the windows themselves and see how they open and close, etc.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2016

Please note that all Profinish Simonton Windows reviews prior to 2015 have been archived.

Top Of Page ˆ

Simonton Windows Reviews : Generations Series

The Simonton Generations window is a relabeled Reflections 5500 series that is sold under the name in certain regions. In general, the 5500 series gets quite good marks from contractors and industry experts. Scroll down to read all of our Simonton Windows reviews on the Generations Series.

Dane - Site Editor

Windows Parts Complaint

Elizabeth wrote: I bought (9) windows back in 2011 and everyone of them have had the same problems. When I raised and lower them the Denny Clip Pivot System breaks. When I clean windows those item break.

Is there anything that can replace those plastic pieces, so they don”t break. Maybe, make them out of a more durable product instead of Plastic. At the rate that they break, I can’t afford to keep buying them. I’m on a fixed income. Please let me know something

Elizabeth - Homeowner - from 2021

[Site Editor's Answer]

Elizabeth, you would have to contact a local Simonton dealer or a company in your area that sells Simonton windows. They would (should) be the best source of information. You could check with Home Depot, who often sells them and explain the situation. They might have a fix for you or could direct you where to go.

Swisco.com is the best place I know of to buy replacement window parts, that might be where they direct you to go to solve the problem. I wish I had a better answer for you! Dane - Site Editor - from 2021

Simonton Windows Cost vs. Milgard

Thanks Dane, I made 5 appts this week for bids. The appt on Friday is a Simonton bid. He was pretty open about pricing instead of trying to hide behind a single/total bid amount. Simonton 164"x90" 4 panel sliding door is $5,500. Based on the existing windows and doors, most likely need a new engineered header at $2,500 and about $1,000 for drywall/stucco refinishing.

We decided to just assume the builder in this 2004 home went with a non-continuous header between the existing 3 windows and door. Since they are all separated about half-a-foot each leaving from to put studs in between for cheaper support. I'll probably tear out some drywall tonight to confirm the size of the header in there now.

He also mentioned he installs milgard but they tend to use a fatter/wider frame which I don't particularly like. He mentioned the mfg's that use fatter frames, does the glass tend to be thinner?

Thanks for all of your Simonton Windows Reviews and advice for us newbs, so great.

Dante - Homeowner - from 2021

[Site Editor's Answer]

Dante, I think Simonton and Milgard would generally use the same glass thickness for their sliding glass doors, but it will vary by the series. I would ask him directly what glass thickness they use and get an estimate from him on both the Milgard and Simonton to compare prices and specs. I would rate the products generally the same, so if you like the thinner Simonton frame than that is obviously a plus in their column.

Dane - Site Editor - from 2021

Need Your Input On Sliding Glass Door

Hi Dane and Tim, I came across your website and you have great info. on replacement windows. We are rehabbing a house that we’re moving into. We plan to put in a sliding glass door in a new space, i.e. cutting a hole in the wall to add a door. This will go outside to the deck. We plan to go with a standard width but need to special order due to height limitations (sloped ceiling, lower header).

I don’t need anything fancy, but would like something that won’t leak air and feels “solid” when opening and closing. We got a couple of quotes through Lowes and Menards, but I wanted to pick your brain and see if you had any suggestions on where to go for a special order sliding glass door. We’re in Westerville, in case you wondered. Thanks for your input!

Karen - Homeowner - from 2020

[Website Editor Reply]

Karen, most of the windows and doors from Lowes and Menards are lower quality products. Not always but true, but generally so. I would suggest getting a bid on a patio door from a Sunrise dealer, an Okna dealer, and a Soft-Lite dealer. These might be over your budget though. If that's the case, I would get a bid from perhaps a quality Simonton dealer in your area. Simonton and Ply Gem make a quality mid range product line. Wincore might be available in your area, as well as a Vytex dealer. These are the companies that I think will be around you and carry quality sliding doors.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2020

Simonton Generations Window Review

We are researching replacement windows for our 15 yo house in Spring, TX (north of Houston). The two companies we have looked so far are: Simonton (Generations series) and AWS (American Window System). I was unable to find any reviews on AWS on your website. Do you know anything about them? We looked at them sample windows they look a little rough made, but $3k cheaper than what Simonton wants. Just wondering if you can provide any comments on AWS. Much appreciated!!

Anna - Homeowner - from 2016

[Site Editor's Answer]

Anna, I have never heard of American Window Systems out of Texas. I took a look at their website, they have a lot of models so it was unclear which window you were talking about. In general, you get what you pay for in the window industry (but not always) and I have to imagine that true of this very regional vinyl window manufacturer (who I've never heard of and who isn't listed on the nrfc.org website as far as I can tell).

The Simonton Generations Windows are I believe the Reflections 5500 window (or very very close), which is one of their better models. I think the name is simply a marketing deal -- just to make it more confusing!

If it were me, I would forget the AWS and instead get a couple more bids from local companies who carry the Milgard Tuscany and the Don Young mid range vinyl window. This should be comparing apples-to-apples and will give you a better product sampling to compare.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2016

Top Of Page ˆ

Simonton Bay And Bow Window Reviews

Simonton makes good bay and bow windows. Like most manufacturers, they purchase the bay box from another company and then add their own windows into the premade bay or bow. This isn't always the case, especially with bow windows, which might be made on site of a project. Therefore, a "Simonton Bay Window" doesn't tell you what you need to know -- you want to know what series you are buying from Simonton. Scroll down to read all of our Simonton Windows reviews on their Bay And Bow Series.

Dane - Site Editor

Bay Windows

I was considering getting an argon Simonton bay. What's your opinion on these?

Silvia - Homeowner - from 2023

[Site Editor's Answer]

Hey there -- simonton makes a good window in their Impressions series and their Reflections 5500 series. Simonton bay windows are solid -- most companies send their "bay window" orders to one of three companies who make the bay box and then the company simply places their windows into the openings and voila, a bay window. Installation is key when it comes to bay windows as these are complex installs and there are plenty of places to screw them up. I would definitely suggest getting multiple bids as bay window price quotes can vary widely (just like with any more complex install). If you'd like a list of additional brands and options, I'm happy to send something your way --

Dane - Site Editor - from 2023

Simonton vs United

Hi Tim, my contractor quoted 3 prices for replacing my bow window for United (2 options - $3,794 & $4,089) and Simonton ($4,658). Is Simonton a better option than United? If I want to price a higher quality "brand" than Simonton, what manufacturers would you recommend?

My home is 60 yr old split level and my wife & I plan to stay in the house maybe 5-10 more years. What level of quality do you recommend that we invest in for this project?

Jim - Homeowner - from 2017

[Site Editor's Answer]

Jim, Simonton is absolutely the better window compared with United windows (I do think our Simonton Windows reviews page back this up). I would definitely recommend going with the Simonton option, even if you aren't in your forever home. It's not like Simonton is the most expensive window out there, it's more in that mid range and is appropriate for your timeline. Both companies probably buy the actual bow/bay window box from the few companies that specialize in making them so there will be very little difference there.

I would still go back to the Simonton dealer and tell him you have another bid for $4,000 and say if he can get close to that price, you are ready and willing to sign right then...see what he says.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2017

Top Of Page ˆ

Simonton Windows Reviews : StormBreaker Plus

The StormBreaker Plus is Simonton's impact or hurricane window and is considered a good impact window option that gets the job done, without breaking the bank. It is often considered one, if not the best, of Simonton's vinyl window series.

The StormBreaker Plus uses a 0.90 inch glass interlayer. (As a point of reference, the Simonton Impressions 9800 series can be upgraded to a hurricane compliant window but has a 0.60 inch glass interlayer.) The StormBreaker also uses a laminated glass and a steel sash reinforcement. Consumers can expect a 60 to 80 design pressure rating, which is quite impressive. (Most vinyl windows come standard with a 25 to 40 DP rating.) I would give the Simonton StormBreaker Plus Series Window a 4.3 out of 5 stars rating. Scroll down to read all of our Simonton Windows reviews on the Stormbreaker series.

Dane - Site Editor

Storm Breaker Plus vs Viwintech

Hi! I’m enjoying reading your reviews but am now even more confused. My mom and I have gotten quotes for our townhomes for double-hung (or sliders) & three-light sliding patio doors. The problem is, of course, that we can’t make a comparison due to all different window brands. We’re a couple of old ladies and are afraid of being taken advantage of (well, she’s 94…I’m a little younger☺️).

HD: Simonton Storm Breaker Plus and/or PGT Protect-Sure

Lowe’s: Pella, but he didn’t tell me which series

Window World: Whatever their 8000 series is

Hometown Contractors: Viwinco

And another local shop: Viwintech (windows) & Shwinco (door)

Window World came with $9K

HD&Lowes & the local guy average around $14K

Hometown started at $25K and then “discounted” to $15K, but only if we signed right away.

My head is ready to explode from researching—which I’d why I’m hoping to get advice from experts.

Kathi - Homeowner - from 2021

[Site Editor's Answer]

Kathi, the Simonton Storm Breaker Plus and/or PGT Protect-Sure are the best of the bunch in my opinion. However, I'm always wary of Home Depot's installation teams. It's kind of a mixed bag.

Do a google search for "PGT windows in [your city, state]" (as an example), which should bring up local companies who carry the brand. I would love to see how the prices from the actual PGT or Simonton rep/local company compare to HD. Check their online reviews to make sure they are a quality outfit.

I would stay away from Window World for the most part.

Viwintech is decent, but I would prefer PGT myself.

The other option to look at is Custom Window Systems (CWS), which will have a rep in your area. They make a quality window as well.

PGT, CWS, and Simonton Stormbreaker are all good options in Florida for storm windows and doors (assuming that that's what you are looking for).

Dane - Site Editor - from 2021

Stormbreaker Plus vs Oceanview

Good morning. I'm in a quandary and do not really know which way to turn so I'm turning to you and your expertise. Thoughts? Advice? Which would you out on your Florida home? In a nutshell, I'm comparing Simonton Stormbreaker Plus to ViWinco Ocenview. Pricing is within a few hundred dollars between two highly rated contractors.

However, I don't even want to try and understand the technical differences between the two manufacturers. The only difference that I see is one is written for single hung and the other is written for double hung. Also, both are within the budget we have. Much thanks for your help!! We have 13 windows and 3 doors.

Simonton Stormbreaker Plus: $21080

Viwinco Ocenview: $20,741.5

Whatever Simonton windows reviews information you'd be able impart would be greatly appreciated.

Greg - Homeowner - from 2021

[Site Editor's Answer]

Greg, these two windows are pretty close to one another. I'm not sure I would rate one over the other in any appreciable way. If this were my project, I would make the decision based on the company doing the install over these two similar products. I checked on Sash and Sill - Window installation service in Fruitville, Florida.

4.9 Google Reviews. This is pretty amazing -- a lower price and a company that gets truly amazing reviews. I'd be leaning towards this bid.

Dane - Site Editor - from 2021

Simonton Stormbreaker Bid

So my estimates came back $15,785 for 9 Windows -$2000 for advertising in my yard. Simonton stormbreaker. A bit high would you figure?

Gary - Homeowner - from 2020

[Website Editor Reply]

Gary, I normally wouldn't expect the Simonton Stormbreaker to cost more that $1000 a window. Seems very high to me.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2020

[Gary's Reply]

Thank you for getting back with me one more question please. Have you heard of or do you have any information on the Simonton Pearl Bay Coastal series hurricane window? Thank you sir.

Gary - Homeowner - from 2020

[Website Editor Reply]

Quite a good product and hopefully less than the other quote you had!

Dane - Website Editor - from 2020

Simonton Stormbreaker Plus

Hi Dane, we live in Florida along the Gulf in a three story townhome sharing one wall with another unit. The community was built in 2005-2006. All 19 windows & 4 SGDs are in need of replacement. We’re looking for good quality (window & installation) without breaking the bank. We’ve narrowed our product selection to Simonton Stormbreaker Plus (including ProSolar Shade w/ Argon Gas option) & PGT Wingard Impact (low E 70 XL Argon filled, insulated glass).

We’re getting quotes from 5 contractors. Only one offers both Simonton & PGT. We’ve eliminate 2 on the basis of cost. We’d appreciate your guidance in the following areas: 1) Glass quality: we understand that Simonton uses Cardinal glass & PGT uses Vitro (formerly PPG). Is one better than the other.

2) Vinyl: we were told that Simonton uses 70% pure vinyl & PGT uses virgin vinyl. If this is true, is one “better” than the other?, 3) Double hung (DH) vs Single hung (SH): aside from ease of cleaning the outside of a DH & the option to lower the top sash for cross ventilation are there other significant considerations that should guide our selection of one over the other.

One sales person encouraged us to go with single hung b/c its more “structurally sound” and doesn’t present the challenges of opening and closing the window (top sash much heavier than a normal window & getting top & bottom sash position correctly for closing can be difficult.). Is there any way to confirm the window mfg’s estimated delivery time? Lastly, we’d like to make the contract time bound (i.e., project to be completed in 3 mos.). Thoughts? We welcome any other significant points of consideration that will help guide our decision. Thank you in advance for your Simonton windows reviews and all of your help.

Pamela - Homeowner - from 2020

[Website Editor Reply]

Hi Pamela, so I really like the two choices -- perfect for a good quality product without breaking the bank. Honestly, these two products are just about even with one another. If I had to give the nod to one or the other, I would say the PGT Winpact is a little bit better. However, the installation company would be the much bigger factor in making my decision than the small difference in product quality.

Cardinal and PPG, now Vitro Architectural Glass, are essentially the two most popular glass manufacturers for home windows and they are equal in quality.

Both of these companies use the same quality vinyl extrusions, totally equal in my opinion.

Some single hung are made with inferior components compared to double hung windows, but this isn't always the case. Both Simonton and PGT make good quality single hung windows and I personally agree that single hungs here offer better energy efficiency and less parts that need to be replaced. The energy efficiency data bears this out, but you can always ask for the numbers if they have the structural and efficiency data.

No way to guarantee estimated delivery time especially with the health outbreak. That is going to be more a factor of whether the company is on their game or not. Being a stickler for the details when you go over the work order is the best way to show the dealer or seller that you are a homeowner who wants things done the way they should be done. This applies to all home improvement projects.

Ask about the timeline on the project, refer back to this timeline every week or so and let the job manager know that keeping on his original schedule is important to you and something that you expect to happen. This is my best advise. The squeaky wheel gets the grease -- very true on home improvement projects.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2020

Simonton Stormbreaker vs. Viwinco OceanView

Tim, we were considering the Viwinco OceanView impact window but now I think we may be headed toward a Simonton Stormbreaker. We live in one of 4 condos that use about 30 windows each of the Simonton Pro Finish Masters that are about 13 years old and out of 120+ windows have had only one issue (other than pivot pins) and that was a seal. I spoke to Simonton this morning about their product for our new home and found out what we had was under warranty still. I was quite pleased! VERY helpful customer service lady named Natalie Card.

Anyway, thanks for your recommendation and if any of our experience is of value I would be happy to do a writeup with pics and such for your page both for the old and the new.

Bill - Homeowner - from 2019

[Site Editor's Answer]

Bill, great to hear your experience with the Simonton rep went so well. I think the Simonton Stormbreaker is a quality impact window and one that should serve you well. Good luck on your project!

Dane - Site Editor - from 2019

Simonton Storm Breaker Plus vs. CWS 8100 Series

We have two large sliding doors and a handful of windows that need to be replaced in our Florida condo. The Simonton Storm Breaker Plus bid is $2000 less than the bid from the contractor using the CWS 8100 and 8200 for the windows and 8800 doors.

Can you provide me with some insight into which option you would go with.

Laura - Homeowner - from 2018

[Website Editor Reply]

Laura, both companies have a solid reputation for impact windows, although CWS is probably better known for their focus on impact windows. I do like the Simonton Storm Breaker Plus though -- it's a good impact window/door. The CWS 8000 models are quite good.

I would basically say that the two products are on par with one another. Therefore, all things being equal in the installation department, I'd go with the cheaper of the two.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2018

StormBreaker Plus Glass Issue

Hello Dane, I have had windows replaced with StormBreaker Plus form Simonton Windows. The two window sliders are perfect and have a normal reflection. The windows look clear with no distortion in the reflection from the outside.

The larger three pane slider is the concern. The fixed center window and the two sliding windows have a diffused reflection. In other words the windows have a waviness and causes the reflection to be distorted. This is due to an uneven surface that causes many deviations at the vertex where the point of incidence and the point of reflection meet. The waviness causes many points of contact with deviations in the angle of reflection.

This results in such a bizarre reflection and a wavy pattern when viewing the window from the outside. Minor waviness is stated in the warranty information as being outside of the warranty, but when such large distortion is noticeable it should be covered under warranty.

Steve - Homeowner - from 2018

Simonton Storm Breaker vs. Eastern Architectural

Hey Dane, looking at Simonton Storm Breaker 300 VL or Eastern Architectural windows for Clearwater, fl......10 windows various sizes on 4th floor condo....$11900 for Simonton and $11560 for Eastern. Your opinion? Thanks.

Chuck - Homeowner - from 2018

[Website Editor Reply]

Charles, my sort of official position on EAS is that I don't know enough about them to endorse them or not endorse them.

Simonton makes a good mid range vinyl window, although they manufacture a whole slew of models so I would need to know which series...with Simonton I think you need to go with their premium models like the Reflections 5500 or Impressions 9800 series. The Storm Breaker model is quite good as well.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2018

Stormbreaker Plus Impact Windows

Hi Dane, what’s your opinion on Jeld-Wen impact windows? I'm in Florida.

Thank you.

John - Homeowner - from 2018

[Website Editor Reply]

John, I'm not a huge fan of Jeld Wen to be honest and especially not for impact windows. I'm not even sure if they sell an impact window. You should try and find a dealer who sells the Stormbreaker Plus impact window.

They make a good impact window at a reasonable price.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2018

Simonton Coastal Line

Hi Dane, I’m replacing all 17 windows in my 1951 masonry block Florida home with impact windows. We have aluminum awning style windows now (not original). We used Simonton awning style windows in a bath addition we built in 2008 and I like them very much. I like the function of awning style windows - we can leave them open in pleasant weather when its raining. I like the look of three windows stacked (vs. two which looks like a double hung), but mulling three windows together takes a lot of space visually. Suggestions?

Also, I got a quote from Home Depot for the 17 windows a month ago - the Simonton Coastal line - for $24,270. High? About right? With this line of windows, we’d need to add hurricane shutters. Thanks for your advice!

Mary- Homeowner - from 2017

[Site Editor's Answer]

Lots of homeowners will combine awning and casements that can account for different spacial configurations. This keeps the cost down as you don't have to have custom window and installation requirements.

In terms of the Simonton Coastal line costs, that sounds high to me. $1400 per window installed isn't chump change! I would definitely get a bid from PGT and CWS and compare these prices. This will also give you two professional opinions on configuration options etc. Being on site is much easier to give specific opening advise than sight-unseen. Both PGT and CWS are in my opinion better quality windows than Simonton. Get the bids and see how they compare. Feel free to send them back to me and I'm more than happy to give you my two cents.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2017

[Mary's Reply]

Thanks! I had an installer come out yesterday to provide a bid on PGT windows. Apparently hurricane windows aren’t readily available in many sizes in awning, so it’s a combo of awning for the small windows, casement for the medium size windows and sliders for the long runs of windows (75”+ long). In this way, I cut down on the total number of windows (one of the long runs was about 9’ long and currently three windows mulled together).

I appreciate your advice.

Mary- Homeowner - from 2017

Simonton Windows Reviews On The Stormbreaker Plus

We received a quote from FHIA for (7) CWS 8100 windows and (2) 8200 windows for $9,676. The 8200's are 5' and 6' wide. All windows are impact resistant and have Low-E 366 tempered glass. The total area is 93.34 sq feet and based on estimates I found on your page the installed costs should be between $55 & $85 per sq ft.

Ours is about $104/sq ft. FHIA says that their installation includes any remediation required including replacement of any rotted or damaged wood. Does this look like a reasonable price?

Bill - Homeowner - from 2017

[Site Editor's Answer]

Bill, I'm not sure if it's a good bid or not. Impact windows should run at the top end of that price range, so your $104/ sq ft. is obviously higher than that. If there is wood rot in the existing frames or sills, then that price can jump really quickly. I would get two more bids -- one from a local company who sells PGT windows and another from a company who sells the Simonton Stormbreaker Plus. If you can't find the latter, find a Simonton rep who will sell you the 9800 series with the upgrades to make them hurricane compliant.

These two bids should be enough to tell you if your first bid is legit. Then you have three bids to choose from and you can use the bids to work the price down.

Here's some food for thought in terms of getting the bids you get a low as possible!
https://www.replacementwindowsreviews.co/review-topics/negotiating-a-home-window-bid.html

Tim - Site Editor - from 2017

Simonton Stormbreaker Plus vs. Viwinco Oceanview

I'm searching for new construction windows for my coastal home. The builder we are using suggested impact windows and sliding doors from either Simonton or Viwinco. It's one sliding door and maybe 20 double hungs. Any opinions on these two companies? The two products my builder prefers are the windows and sliding glass doors by the two companies mentioned above. Thanks.

Dan - Homeowner - from 2017

[Contractor Response]

The Simonton Stormbreaker is their hurricane window and it's a tank. And it's pretty darn affordable (the Viwinco Oceanview should will less expensive, but it's not as good as the Stormbreaker). In general, Simonton makes a good mid-grade vinyl window and they have very good customer service.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2017

[Dan's Response]

Hey Dane, thanks for the feedback. I was able to get the overall cost dropped by about 23% which put the cost of the Simontons about $1000 more than the Viwinco windows.

Dan - Homeowner - from 2017

[Site Editor's Answer]

Dan, that's a great price reduction, I would say you are set to go with the Simonton Stormbreaker window. It's a very solid impact window that should serve you well.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2017

Simonton StormBreaker Plus vs Eastern Architectural Windows

Can you compare the Simonton StormBreaker Plus vs Eastern Architectural Bertha products for me? I have 11 windows and 3 SGD....all vinyl impact resistant as I live in Cape Coral, FL. Simonton quote was $20k and Eastern was $16k...installed. This is for my young son's starter home and I doubt they'll be there more than 5-7 years. Any input will be greatly appreciated.

Mel - Homeowner - from 2016

[Site Editor's Answer]

Mel, I don't hear much about Eastern Architectural Systems and I tried to download their product brochure but they make you fill out some form. (I wasn't impressed with this tactic given that they should want consumers to know as much about their windows and doors as possible.) Additionally, I know they focus on Florida and I believe they are owned by Eastern Metal. I believe they make a solid vinyl window, but I can't voch for them.

The Stormbreaker Plus is a good impact window that is often sold at a competitive price point. I often recommend this, as well as PGT and Custom Window Systems impact windows for your area. You may want to get a bid from these companies and see how they compare.

Normally, I would say go with the Simonton StormBreaker Plus, tired and true, but the fact that this is a starter home gives me pause. I would say this, compare the U-value, Design Pressure and Air Infiltration numbers between the two windows and see how close they are. If they are close to one another, I think you probably go with the less expensive option.

I always feel sort of guilty with this recommendation because someone down-the-line might bear the cost (the next homeowner), but my advise is for you and not them.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2016

Simonton vs PGT Hurricane Windows

We are forced to replace a large window with two awning windows and two plate glass windows. Total width is 196" and height is 62". We live in Florida, on a river, and close to the gulf - obviously a hurricane zone. Can you compare PGT class C window to Simonton class D window, please. This window faces the south, which is on the river. We have estimates that are very similar in price.

Deanna - Homeowner - from 2016

[Site Editor's Response]

Deanna, PGT in my opinion is the superior window to the Simonton. Now, I will say that the installation quality would push me one way or the other, so if there is a noticeable difference between the two (reviews, reputation, etc.) then this would be my deciding factor.

But all (installation) things being equal, I would have to go with the PGT hurricane windows over Simonton hurricane windows.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2016

Simonton StormBreaker Windows

I'm looking to purchase a home from a builder in Fl. who has won "Builder of The Year" awards on multiple occasions. I'm a bit concerned because he will be using the MI high impact windows (Storm Armor)if I purchase the home. I cannot find any reviews on these MI windows and was wondering if these are rated any better than the non-impact windows they sell. Thanks for your feedback on these windows.

Don - Homeowner - from 2016

[Site Editor's Response]

Don, MI does not have a stellar reputation in the industry, but I know lots of builders like them, I'm assuming because they get them at a good price and they figure the windows are "good enough." I don't know much about the Storm Armor series. I'm sure they are better than the standard MI vinyl windows, but that isn't a recommendation by any means.

I would ask the builder for two other impact options or brands that he could order. If he does, see if you can compare the performance to the Storm Armor, specifcally the Depsign Pressure Rating, U-factor, Air Infiltration Number and Condensation Resistance Rating.

I would ask if he has access to PGT, Custom Window Systems, Stanek or the Simonton StormBreaker Plus window. Without knowing anything about the Storm Armor, I would think that the options I mentioned would be a better long term solutions than the MI. Each of the companies makes a very solid impact window that will be more expensive than the MI, but isn't going to be exorbitant.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2016

Please note that all Stormbreaker Simonton Windows reviews prior to 2015 have been archived.

Top Of Page ˆ

Simonton Impact Windows Reviews

In addition to the Stormbreaker Plus impact window, the company manufacturers one other line called the Simonton Coastal. At some point, they also marketed what they called the Pearl Bay Coastal. Scroll down to read all of our Simonton Windows reviews on their additional impact window series.

Simonton Hurricane Impact Windows

I ordered hurricane impact windows...I got many bids, window Depot was the company I first choose $8500, but when they didn’t return my call for a question, I decided to go with another company with lifetime warranty, free replacement etc. Morgan Exteriors. The other bids I got were for cws and pgt, they were very similar in price, but I didn’t like the windows as much.

I called morgan exteriors and they assured me that three are simonton hurricane impact windows, in small print on label it says simonton. The windows are amazing, installation went smoothly. I’m just waiting for final inspection from county, final service from Morgan exteriors, and an inspection from Duke energy for window rebate.

Thanks for your help.

Cary - Homeowner - from 2018

Coastal Series vs. CWS 8700

Hi Dane, I'm looking for Impact French doors and am considering the CWS 8700 series for the work. Should I be looking at other brands besides the CWS for the project.

Thanks in advance for all of your assistance

Glenda - Homeowner - from 2018

[Website Editor Reply]

Glenda, in addition to CWS, I would put PGT on that list. Those two companies are right on par with one another in terms of windows and doors. As well, I would include the Simonton Coastal and Stormbreaker Plus windows. I think all of these are good companies and they are all relatively fairly priced manufacturers.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2018

Simonton Pearl Bay Series

Simonton Pearl Bay Coastal vs. PGT 5500

Hi Dane, thank you so much for your response.

Yes, we require impact windows in our neighborhood in Florida.

We are down to either Simonton Pearl Bay Coastal or PGT 5500 series. Any recommendations between the two?

Thank you for your time!

Andrea - Homeowner - from 2021

[Site Editor's Answer]

Andrea, these are both quite good impact windows. I think my preference would be the PGT 5500 series. However, they are close enough that I would probably make my selection based on the installation company's reviews and reputation. I think that's the more important factor over these two very close impact windows.

Dane - Site Editor - from 2021

All Pearl Bay Coastal series Simonton Windows reviews prior to 2015 have been archived for your convenience.

Top Of Page ˆ

Simonton Windows Reviews :: Inovo Patio Doors

Innovo Door vs. Sunrise Vanguard

Hi, we recently had an eight foot sliding door shatter. I have 3 quotes:

Midway $3993

Simonton Inovo 5343

Sunrise vanguard 6700

I assume you get what you pay for and quality really goes up by price in these quotes?

I am very concerned with energy efficiency as well. We have 4 sliders on the back of the house, but just one is urgent. 

All of our windows are 20 yr old ROW shoddy windows, we have a lot & many are large and replacing them all at once will be costly.

The Home Depot quote for all window replacement in Simonton 6500 is $39,317

Replacing all with all Sunrise Vanguard is $73,791

Thoughts? Are these windows that much different? Maybe the Vanguard sliders are worth the cost? but windows from Simonton?

Thank you for any help!

Rebecca - Homeowner - from 2022

[Website Editor Reply]

Rebecca, often you get what you pay for. However, Midway is a pretty darn good brand and it is the least expensive for the door. I would say it is equal in quality if not better than the Simonton Innovo. What did the Midway bid come in at for the windows? My big question on the Midway bid would center on the company doing the install. They would have to have great online reviews -- then I would be very tempted to go with them. Google the "[company name] reviews" and see what comes up...

The Sunrise Vanguard is a really excellent product, but that is a HUGE price gap between Simonton and Sunrise...that's too much for the Sunrise...

Incidentally, my replacement window option recommendations in and around Chicago include Okna windows, Sunrise, Soft-Lite, Kensington, Universal Direct, Window Nation, and Great Lakes windows. All of these brands should be available in and around Chicago from local companies.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2022

Simonton Innovo vs. Sunrise Sliding Doors

Tim, I am trying to decide between the Sunrise sliding door and the Simonton Inovo sliding door. Both seem to be well constructed and similar in features. Price wise the Simonton is coming in at a lower cost by about $1000.

Any opinion on which might be the better option to go with?

Greg - Homeowner - from 2017

[Site Editor's Answer]

Greg, Sunrise makes a very good sliding door and Simonton makes a good sliding door. Assuming you like the overall look of the Simonton series, I would save the $1000 and go with that one. The Sunrise is going to be a bit better, but honestly not $1K better.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2017

Simonton Innovo vs ProCraft

I've gotten two bids for my window replacement in the Seattle area (vinyl double pane replacing single-pane aluminum frame) and the numbers are very far apart. I'm getting funny feelings about the use of "house label" from both companies - I'm assuming they use private model numbers exactly to prevent comparisons. One company quoted their ProCraft Pro-8000 series. They state that these are made by CDI in Tacoma (Comfort Design Windows?), but it isn't clear about which model. Have you heard of CDI?

They don't exist in the manufacturer list you have. And their model names don't translate directly. The other company did the same thing - They quoted their "Innova Pro Series" (http://clearnrg.com/products/) which are stated as made by Simonton with some upgrades and such, but aren't clear about which line's frame is used as the base.

By reading your Simonton windows reviews site, I know Simonton can be all over the map in terms of cost, quality and value. As an example of one window in the bid, a 72x42 slider from ProCraft (CDI) was quoted at 932 installed, while the Innovo (Simonton) was quoted at 1596 installed. Even with installation cost of 150 on the window, both seem a little high. And unless its apples and oranges in terms of quality, the latter seems REALLY high. Any thoughts? Definitely time for a third quote, methinks.

Chris - Homeowner - from 2016

[Site Editor's Answer]

Chris, if the installation cost is $150, which seems perfectly reasonable to me, the window cost is REALLY high, especially for ProCraft (never heard of them) and Simonton. Think about it this way, you can go to Home Depot and order an Andersen 100 series (a composite frame that is certainly as good as most Simonton windows) and order that for somewhere in the neighborhood of $450 in that size…this is a guess of course (it might actually be worth your while just to see).

HD always offers really low cost on the windows, but their installation is very hit or miss. Assuming you were to hire someone off of yelp who gets excellent window installation reviews and they charge $150, you'd be looking at $600 fully installed. Now if you found another company who sold the product and did the installation, you might be in the $650 to $750 range, but unless there is something I'm missing, the product cost is high.

Try to find a Milgard dealer and get a bid on the Tuscany model, there must be a bunch up there. Amerimax might be available up there as well. Bottom line is I'd keep looking because that price seems high to me…if the other bids come in at that same range then at least you'll know that something is driving up that cost. Might be worth a call to the HD windows department and see if they can quote you a price on a window with those measurements.

Thanks a bunch for your insight. It confirms my feeling that these prices are either high for what we get or that they are positioning themselves at the high-end and feel that they can justify it with their customizations to these models. I'll keep looking and try to get another couple quotes from window places and home depot too. Love your site - most folks buy windows once or twice in their life, so everybody is a rookie and this sort of info is needed.

Dane - Website Editor - from 2016

Top Of Page ˆ

Simonton Slimline Series

The Slimline series is apparently a reboot of their Daylight Max, which is sold almost exclusively through Home Depot. The Slimline seems to be sold through Window World. Here's the problem, this may or may not be an upgraded window - it may just be relabeled and sold through WW. Often times, dealers are just repeating a line that their managers told them to say. I'm going to do some investigative reporting and see what I can find out. Scroll down to read all of our Simonton windows reviews on the Slimline series.

Dane - Website Editor

Slimline 5000 Series

Dane, thank you for providing me this information - As for Windows World 5000 Slimfit Series, they claim it is essentially the same thing as the Simonton Daylight Max, but better. However, I am unable to find any data to substantiate this claim online, so having an expert such as yourself is very helpful. I understand this is a fairly new window, but still..

I also reached out to them to provide me the NFRC CPD # for the window so I can verify exactly what the U-factor, SHGC, VT, etc. stats are, but interestingly, I cannot find them on the NFRC site: https://search.nfrc.org/search/searchdefault.aspx. I'm assuming it has the same CPD # as the Daylight Max?

Grant - Homeowner - from 2023

[Site Editor's Answer]

Grant, you know more than me about this Slimfit than I do -- sounds like its a reboot -- I'll have to spend some time looking into it!

Dane - Site Editor - from 2023

Top Of Page ˆ

Simonton Windows Reviews : Verona Series

The Verona series pops up on our radar now and again, but by all accounts, the company no longer makes this vinyl window series. Scroll down to read all of our Simonton Windows reviews on the Verona series.

Simonton Verona Series vs. AMI Preservation

We are looking to replace our mobile home windows to save energy & provide a more even heat / cool balance between the North & South ends. My question is between AMI Preservation replacement windows for a 56 year old mobile home versus Simonton Verona Series for same 56 year old mobile home.

I have been told that Simonton Windows ( 6200 or Verona? ) are good vinyl windows for our project by a couple of bidders. Another bidder proposes the AMI Preservation windows.

In listening to the presentations I am leaning more toward the AMI windows based on the design & construction, but am struggling with the added cost.

AMI ~$18K, Simonton 6200's $13K.

What I am hoping you might be able to help me with is: your opinion(s) of which option is better for my situation, or if there is a better solution. Thank you for your help.

14 windows total. I also need to correct age of MobileHome. 46 years old (1972 vintage ).

I would also ask your advice between the AMI & Simonton Verona windows already asked about versus Simonton America’s Dream Prestige Plus windows.

Loren - Homeowner - from 2018

[Website Editor Reply]

Loren, my own take on the AMI Preservation window is that its overpriced for the overall quality of the window. I would say its a better window than the Simonton 6000 series, but not by a lot. Right now though, I'm leaning towards the Simonton quote from a quality installation company. If, however, the AMI installer seems like a better outfit over the Simonton, that would be enough to switch my vote to the Preservation.

I have to say that your two bids seem very expensive. Windows for a mobile home are typically cheaper than for a home. The average cost to buy and install a Milgard Tuscany window is $450 to $500. So why are you looking at such a high cost? Perhaps the windows are big or the installation is complicated...

I think you should look up home window installation on yelp and call up a few of the top companies and get bids from them.

Tim - Site Editor - from 2018

[Loren's Reply]

Thank you Dane, you have confirmed this nagging thought that the AMI & Simonton America’s Dream are not really the best choice. I do have a Milgard quote that is presented more clearly & is considerably less cost.

Thanks again.

Loren - Homeowner - from 2018

Top Of Page ˆ

Related Topics: Quaker Windows Reviews

Apex Windows Reviews