| REVIEWS |  |
BEST WINDOWS | |
WINDOWS PRICES | |
STYLES |
Home : Replacement Windows Reviews : Ply Gem
Ply Gem Windows Reviews
Quick Links
Contractor Series
Pro Series
Premium Series
200 Series
400 Series
50000 Series
6000 Series
9000 Series
Ply Gem Windows Price List
Ply Gem Windows Reviews :: 1200 Series
I need some guidance, I built a new home 8 years ago and I got PlyGem 1200 series windows, since then I have 6 windows that have lost the seal and I can barely see out of them. The place I bought them from has went out of business. What if anything can I do about this. I would hope the company would stand behind their products and help me with this problem..thanks
Yolanda - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Yolanda, google it and see if you can find a company that reps Ply Gem windows. Call them up and ask for a bid on new windows. When they arrive, get the bid but start drilling down on the warranty and if he will cover the replacement of the windows. It’s kind of a crap shoot in these scenarios.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Ply Gem Windows Reviews :: Contractor Series
The Ply Gem Contractor window series is an entry level vinyl option geared towards developers and contractors looking for a budget vinyl window. It doesn't have the quality engineering and design that most homeowners require for a long lasting replacement window. Well suited to rental properties or flipping a house, the Contractor model doesn't have lots of extras and upgrades that make for a quality window. I would give the Ply Gem Contractor Series a out of 5 stars rating.
Dane - Site Editor
Ply Gem Windows Reviews 2023
We have three awning windows that should have been taken out and replaced years ago and would love to get your thoughts on which of these is the better play.
Joyce Heritage - $820 each installed
Ply Gem Contractor - $740 each installed
Tony - Homeowner - from 2023
(Joyce Windows Reviews)
[Site Editor's Answer]
Tony, I would say the Joyce option is the better one here. The Ply Gem contractor is an entry level series, while the Heritage is a much better made window in my opinion.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
PlyGem Windows Complaints
Hi Guys, I’m reading your reviews, and my contractor (on a repair job in my master regarding four 6 foot tall bay/picture windows) used a local distributor (Construction Solutions & Supply) and they installed PlyGem windows. Two of the four brand new windows leaked immediately then this installer came out and replaced the glass and resealed on both of the faulty windows; subsequently, one leaked immediately then the other leaked one week later.
A great friend of mine is a contractor and he's never had a problem with PlyGem; however, the company who sold us and installed these PlyGem windows that they've experienced leaking with this manufacturer lately.
My house is 1 mile from the beach (on an island) and next to the intracoastal here in Jacksonville, FL. We get pounded with heavy winds, rains, nor'easters and hurricanes every year - multiple times. What brand and model would you truly recommend? The window distributor has recommended we us the Viwinco Cambridge windows, tempered glass.
Given our problems and what i've shared do you A) recommend this Viwinco brand and model (I've read mixed reviews), or B) do you have other brands and models to recommend? Keep in mind our home was build in 2001 and is concrete block, tile roof, with aluminum windows.
Brandon - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Brandon, sorry for your troubles, it sounds like a total headache and money-suck. I've generally had good experience with the PlyGem Premium, and to a lesser extent, the Pro model. I hadn't heard about an uptick in leaking issues, but certainly it is on my radar now.
The Viwinco Cambridge is a decent vinyl window, a pretty solid second tier option. You can expect a a .29 U-factor, .19 SHGC, .11 AI, DP35, and an 57 CR.
The other companies I typically recommend in Florida include the PGT Winguard or 5400 series, Custom Window Systems 600 Series, or the Simonton Impressions and Reflections 500 series. Given quality installation, these seem to all be solid consumer options.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2018
Ply Gem Windows Reviews vs Milgard
Hi there, we are in the process of building a new home and our contractor has suggested a builder grade PlyGem window. It seems like the Pro model from them would be better.
We also have access to the Milgard Hermosa, which is made here in Dallas.Our contractor also seems to have access to the Burris TectView EX window.
We want a quality product but not necessarily the highest end product required.
Pricewise here is what we have.
Ply Gem Builder Series: $4,400
Milgard Style Line Series: $6700
Milgard Hermosa Series: $7300
Milgard Tuscany Series: $8500
Sherry - Homeowner - from 2018
[Site Editor's Response]
Sherry, the Milgard Tuscany is a solid choice and worth the extra cost from the Style Line. I think the same could be said of the Hermosa line.
Sunrise should have local dealer in your area.
I think the top windows from NT or Burris ought to be decent selections as well. I particularly like the NT Presidential window.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2018
Ply Gem Windows Reviews vs Vinylmax
I was looking at Plygems and Vinylmax Windows, the Vinylmax seems stronger and the welds look nicer, plus it has a lifetime warranty vs 25 for Plygem. The Vinylmax is $60 more each window, and I'm not sure if they are worth that much more? I don't mind paying it if they're worth it but I hate wasting money.
Peter - Homeowner - from 2012
[Contractor Response]
What are the numbers? You want to compare SHGC, u-values, and the DP and AI ratings. I don't know much about Vinylmax windows prices. They look like they have some nice features, but I know Plygems and I'd feel more comfortable recommending a company I know well than one I don't. Also, I don't know where you got your warranty info but Plygem has a lifetime transferable warranty.
Harry - Contractor - from 2012
Ply Gem Windows Reviews :: Pro Series
The Ply Gem Pro Series is their mid range vinyl window, in between their entry level Contractor and their high end Premium Series. The Pro model is considered a solid mid range vinyl window. Having said that, I think there are better mid range vinyl windows out there, including the Milgard Tuscany window, Champion vinyl windows, and the Okna 400 Series. However, these will also be more expensive than the Ply Gem Pro. I would say that the Ply Gem Pro and Premium windows are good buys given the right price point and solid installation. I would give the Ply Gem Pro Series a out of 5 stars rating.
Dane - Site Editor
Ply Gem Pro Windows Prices
Hello, I misunderstood the bid on the Ply Gem Pro…it was 10,000 rather than 8800. This is for 20 windows. Would you still go with the Ply Gem Pro for 10 rather than Perfexion Gold for 12200? thanks again.
Chris - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Yes, Chris, I still think the Ply Gem Pro for $500 per window is the better deal than $610 per window for the Perfection Gold. Close but still worth it. But the quality of the installation company should play a big role in the decision here.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2020
Ply Gem s6000 Series
Hello, am replacing 20 windows. So far I have received a bid of 12,200 on the Simonton Perfexion, white inside, tan out. The PlyGem Pro series is a bid of 8500, and they come in the same color of white inside and tan out. Can I trust PlyGem? I believe these are good installers. Thanks so much.
Chris - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Hi Chris, so the PlyGem Pro is a nice mid range vinyl window. Here are the pros and cons of PlyGem Windows. The company owns Simonton so if you trust Simonton, you by default trust PlyGem. The s6000 series for $8500 is the much better deal than the Simonton Perfexion series for $12.2K. The Ply Gem bid is pretty cheap so you might want to upgrade to a better glass or consider a sill reinforcement to bolster the overall strength of the window.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2020
Ply Gem Pro Series 200
Hi Dane, I recently received a quote to replace 3 windows. Pro Series 200 ($603) vs Jeld-Wen W-2500 ($1,525). I’m in a 100 year old (uninsulated) brick and vinyl house in memphis tn. Not particularly worried about whether these are overly efficient or not. I’m more concerned with whether they’ll simply last for 20+ years and not leak.
For more than twice the price, I don’t want to cheap out if it’ll cost me down the line. But at the same time, I don’t want to pay unnecessary money for only a slight improvement. Please help a first time homeowner.
Thanks!
Chris - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Chris, the Pro 200 series is the better deal by far here. Really low price on the window. I would ask about any upgrades, such as a sill reinforcement or glass upgrade, that might help strengthen the window or give some better glass efficiency.
Installation is going to be a big factor and that price is suspiciously low. Assuming the PlyGem installer is good, the windows should last 20 plus years.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2019
[Chris's Reply]
Thanks for the response Dane. I should’ve mentioned that these are just sash replacements and not the entire window.
I have a lot of confidence in my installer as all he works on are these older homes in midtown memphis. As opposed to your average installer who may not be ready to deal with not plumb walls and other oddities that these lovely homes are unfortunately cursed with!
Chris - Homeowner - from 2019
Ply Gem Classic and the NT Executive
Hi Tim, we have narrowed it down to either the NT (still need to determine which line they quoted) and the PlyGem which the installer stated was the 7100 series. Do you have any thoughts on a leader between these two. Quote is roughly $1800 less for the NT. Rep did say that he has had some complaints about the green tint to the glass on the NT?
Thanks for your help.
Patrick - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Patrick, the Ply Gem Classic and the NT Executive are very comparable windows to one another. I’d put them in the “solid mid range” category. I would insist on seeing the glass on the NT before going forward to see if its an issue. It tends to be a taste thing — some people have a problem with certain low-e coatings, while others couldn’t care less.
If the glass is good for you, I’d probably lean towards the NT Executive for the $1800 savings. This decision would be predicated on the company doing the install. If I had a better feeling about the Ply Gem installer, I would go with them and eat the $1800. You could always go back to the Ply Gem dealer and ask if he’s willing to match the NT price. Always worth a shot in my book.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2019
Ply Gem Pro vs. Enviroguard Composite
Hello, we are replacing our windows with a rot proof composite option. We have two ideas from local distributors -- the Enviroguard or the Ply Gem Pro? We live in a 1950 cedar shake cottage from the 1950s.
Myra - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Myra, the Enviroguard is a bit of a mystery to me. It is a composite window and when I looked at their website, I wasn't overly impressed with their performance data for the price point. The Ply Gem Pro or Premium series is a quality vinyl window. Of the two options you have, the Ply Gem Pro with an upgraded glass package and perhaps a reinforced sill upgrade would be my preference.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2019
Ply Gem Pro Series
We are replacing 11 sliding windows, 1 kitchen garden window, and 2 sliding patio doors. These are my final two bids, but I can't decide which is the one I should go with. I'd love to get your perspective. Both the salesman said their brand of window was better than the other. Shocker. I couldn't find out much on the Triassic series online.
Pro Series: $11,385
Milgard Trinsic Series: $14,295
Jon - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Jon, I would say the Pro is the better deal for the bid price you have. The Milgard Triassic is the new modern vinyl window from Milgard and I think I pretty good window. It's nice and sleek and gets decent numbers.
For $3K less, I would go with the Ply Gem Pro though.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2018
Ply Gem Windows vs. Reliabilt
Hello Dane and Tim. Will you please give me your professional opinion as to what you think about the Reliabilt 3900 series they carry at Lowe's Hardware?
Also what you think about the Ply Gem Pro Series?
We are building a new house and are going to have it Energy Star rated windows and all.
Thanks so much and enjoy your day.
Beautiful Thoughts.
Allana - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Allana, the Reliabilt Window 3900 series is the company's top end window, but is really no better than a mid range vinyl window. It's probably comparable to the Ply Gem Pro. It might give the nod the the Ply Gem Pro. Neither one is a world beater by any stretch of the imagination. Assuming good installation, either of these is fine for lots of projects. Are there better windows, absolutely. Could you do worse than these, absolutely.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2018
Ply Gem Windows Reviews
Hi Dane. Our builder used the ply gem pro series and I had issues with them while still in the building phase. They were complicated to lock. You push bottom sash down and top sash comes with it, not allowing you to line up the lock without pushing/pulling and leaning into it to line up locks. They had the rep lubricate the tracks a little better, but now I noticed when it's locked shut and supposedly sealed I can see daylight in the corners and feel air coming in from these small openings.
Is this a window issue or bad installation. The house is brand new; not happy with these windows. Have you heard this issue before?
Vicki - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Answer]
Vicki, the locks not lining up could be an installation issue. The fact that you can see daylight in the corners is DEFINITELY an installation issue. Window openings are holes in your walls and if you can see through to the other side, that's about as bad as you can get. Talk about losing money on heat and/or cooling costs.
If I were you, I might do this -- call up one or two local window companies and say you may need to replace a couple of windows. Have them come out and give you a bid (...even though you aren't going to go with them...) Get their opinion and ask what they would charge to re-install the window(s) that you are having an issue with.
I hate offering this advice, but it does provide you with a couple of real opinions and perhaps some pricing to have it done right. If they say its an installation problem, see if they can put that in writing and maybe go back to the builder. I have a feeling you aren't going to get much satisfaction from the builder, but it's worth a shot. If the builder refuses, tell him that you are going to report him to the BBB and will provide a very real review of them on yelp, etc. That may get their attention.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2017
Ply Gem Windows vs Amerimax
Hi Dane, got a question for you on retrofit replacements. We are planning on replacing our old metal framed windows with new vinyl windows. We've met with several contractors on this. Trying to decide on Ply Gem Pro Series or Amerimax Craftsmen Portrait series. Please let me know what you think.
Appreciate the help.
Nicole - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Answer]
Nicole, those two windows are pretty close in terms of performance and overall construction. I like both of these windows and they should serve you well. I would probably lean towards the Amerimax Craftsmen Portrait myself, however the much smarter thing to do is consider the windows equal and turn your attention to the company/installers doing the work. (Read more on Amerimax Windows cost here.)
This is going to make the bigger difference in the long run. Choose the company with the better track record, the more thorough explanation of the install, the better labor warranty, who gives you the best price, and who your gut tells you will do the better job.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2017
Ply Gem Pro vs Milgard Tuscany
Hi Tim, I have a project with 26 windows and two bids. So far its $16,000 for the Milgard Tuscany and $10500 for the Pro. I need triple pane glass in my bedrooms, which will cost more with Milgard over Ply Gem for that upgrade. Can you give me the pros and cons of these windows. Thanks so much and I really appreciate your website!
Kat - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Response]
Kat, performance wise, the Pro is going to have an air infiltration of something like .13, while the Milgard Tuscany will be slightly better at .10. However, those are such huge price differences that I would say you have to go with the Ply Gem Pro. Unless the Milgard rep is willing to come down off his price, I don't see how you can pay that much more for the Milgard Tuscany.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2016
Ply Gem vs Jeld-Wen
We are replacing our double hungs, 36 in all. We are using new construction windows with an exterior brick molding. We have two options that we are looking at: the Plygem Pro Series 400 (a pvc frame) and the Jeldwen Siteline EX window. Which would you say is the better window option. Thanks.
Susan - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Response]
Susan, those are two very different windows. The JELD-WEN Siteline EX window does use an aura last treatment that supposedly protects the wood on the windows and carries a lifetime warranty. I haven't heard how effective this is long term. Definitely something to think about.
The PG Pro is a good middle of the road vinyl window. It's kind of a toss up for me in this regard.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2016
Ply Gem Windows vs Alside Mezzo
I have received quotes for Alside Mezzo and PlyGem Pro double hungs. The Mezzo was cheaper. Which would you recommend?
Stephanie - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Response]
Robert, I would say the Alside Mezzo and PlyGem Pro are pretty comparable in terms of quality and performance. Both of them are pretty solid middle of the road vinyl windows. I would say go with the cheaper of the two, although I would add that the installer would a bigger factor for me than the window. The quality (lack of quality) of the installation will affect performance more than the window itself.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2016
Ply Gem Pro Series 200 Reviews
Having all new 200 Pro Series, white vinyl windows with the low E HP2+ package; Auto locks, insert Argon gas in IGUs, and 2 layers of low-e film, on two panes of glass and limited lifetime manufactures warranty. This a condo complex with 14 buildings and 28 units.
The board feels good about are contractor Pacific Exteriors LLC but management has questions as too the quality of these windows. There pushing for another contractor and is explained as least expensive vinyl window and SGD series available Energy star rating suitable for this application. Think they said available at Home Depot. Appreciate any info you can give.
Marlene - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Response]
Hi Marlene, the Ply Gem Pro window is probably on par with any of the Home Depot replacement windows. It is a mid range vinyl window, although perhaps at the slightly lower end of this range. Is it the best window out there? Definitely not, but if the contractor likes the window, has experience installing it, and is going to provide quality installation, then I would have no issues putting this in.
In order to compare the Ply Gem Pro to another window, I would really have to know what window it is. In general, I would say that the windows are half the equation, and the installation is the other half. So if you get a better window, but the installation isn't done right, you haven't done yourself any favors.
You are near Seattle so I would suggest getting a bid from a Milgard rep and seeing how the Milgard Tuscany compares in price. Perhaps also a local company who sells the Reflections and Impressions series from Simonton. See how these compare as well.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2016
Ply Gem Pro vs Jeld Wen Brickmould
We are getting ready to build a new home on the North Carolina coast, we have the contract in hand. All of our preparatory talks had been about Jeld Wen Brickmould Vinyl Double Hungs. The contract we just received has Ply Gem windows on it. We had been given a Ply Gem Pro Series 400 Double Hung Wood Composite flyer but had never discussed these windows. We have not discussed this change with the contractor yet as we are trying to gather information so that we can have an informed discussion.
How do these two windows compare, what are the differences and advantages/disadvantages. I have spent the last two days trying to search on the internet but do not have enough background knowledge to make an informed decision. Thank you for any help you can provide.
Brenda - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Response]
The Pro Series is a decent window. It wouldn't be my top choice, but I like it over the Jeld Wen option, I'll say that. I think that as long as you get good installation with the Ply Gem Pro window and everything is done well, you should be fine. The problem with windows is that you don't see problems until 5 years down the road, after the labor warranties have expired and the contractor is who knows where.
I'm confused why you had a contract with one brand on it and suddenly got something else. That would bring up a red flag for me.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2016
Ply Gem Windows vs Milgard
The the Ply Gem Pro or Milgard Styline better? How would the Milgard Tuscany compare with the Ply Gem Pro compare?
Mike - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Response]
Mike, both of these windows are close in overall quality. The Pro has a bit more robust frame over the Styleline, but the performance data is pretty similar. The would rate the Tuscany series a bit better than the Ply Gem Pro. The Tuscany will run around 15% more than the Style Line.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2016
Ply Gem MW Pro Series Classic
I am renovating a home which requires both replacement and new build windows. Options presented to me include: MW pro series classic and Jeld Wen Brick mould Vinyl Series (a.k.a. V-2500). I am not overly impressed with either option. I am looking for a solid mid-level window and will be installing 61 windows. Mid-Atlantic area. thoughts on these two options? Any suggestions?
Jennifer - Homeowner - from 2015
[Editor's Response]
Jennifer, these are both okay options, but not great. Companies I would suggest looking at in your area include Sunrise, Soft-Lite, Okna, Polaris, Alpen, and Vytex.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2015
Ply Gem Pro vs. Simonton Daylight Max
Would you recommend the Ply Gem Pro or the Simonton Daylight Max window above the other?
Gwenneth - Homeowner - from 2015
[Site Editor's Response]
Gwenneth, I would give the nod to the Daylight Max from Simonton. Ply Gem actually now owns Simonton, which makes for an interesting comparison. I like the Simonton numbers and the performance data out on this window. These two are mid range vinyl windows.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2015
Ply Gem Windows Reviews MW Pro
We're building a new house, and the builder has MW Pro vinyl windows in the proposal. Is that a good window? I want a good window, but we can't afford the premium brands. Will these do well or is there something better that we should look at, but that doesn't cost a lot more?
Ray - Homeowner - from 2010
[Contractor Response]
Plygem is usually a really good choice, but the MW Pro Series are from the Great Lakes line and I really don't like them. They're a builder window, and Plygem isn't even selling it themselves now. Look at Plygems Premium, Pro, or Contractor Series. They are all good, and I'd recommend the best one you can afford unless you want to go cheap and plan on replacing them in 5-10 years.
Harry - Installer - from 2010
Ply Gem Windows Reviews :: Premium Series
The Ply Gem Premium window series is a good vinyl window - probably comparable in quality and price to the Soft-Lite Classic window. Ply Gem windows aren't going to the best vinyl windows in the business, but they are solid windows that should be just fine if the installation is done thoroughly and correctly. The bottom line is that the Ply Gem Pro and Premium windows are good buys given the right price point and professional installation.
Ply Gem offers a slightly unique warranty on each of their different products so make sure you read the warranty that applies to the exact series you are considering buying. Typically, their windows come with a limited lifetime warranty on the vinyl and components, 2 years on metal and hardware, 20 years on the insulated glass units (this is a prorated amount) and a 1 year on glass defects. All in all, an okay but not great warranty. I would give the Ply Gem Premium Series a out of 5 stars rating.
Dane - Site Editor
Premium Series vs Sunrise
I'm in Michigan and need to replace the following: one bay, 4 double hungs, 5 casements, and one large 1 picture window. Any guidance is much appreciated!
Renewal by Anderson: $34K
Sunrise (triple pane): $17.8K
Gentek Signature Elite: $12.8K
Ply Gem Premium: $12K
Ryan - Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
Ryan, for me the winner here is the triple pane Sunrise. The Ply Gem premium at that low price is a consideration if the company that gave you the bid has good reviews and if you aren't in the home for 20 plus years.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
Ply Gem Windows Reviews On The Premium
Hi Dane, thank you for your website. It's been very helpful! We're in the process of choosing a vinyl window replacement brand for our home renovation project that also includes a new roof and siding. So this is a big project! We live in northern NJ and have received a few quotes and wanted to get your opinion on the different brands. We are looking to replace 25 windows. This includes 3 picture windows and 22 double hungs. All except 1 picture window will have 6 over 6 grids too. The prices are all within $3-5k of each other but we're not sure what is the better choice.
Viwinco Cambridge (Viwinco Windows Cost)
Simonton Reflections 5500
Plygem Premium
Vinylmax Newton or Edison
Vinylmax 4700 - we didn't get a price for this but saw that this is Vinylmax most economical so wanted to see if you had any thoughts on this line
Thank you for your help.
Joan & Dan - Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
Hi Joan and Dan, I would rank them like this: The Vinylmax Newton and Simonton Reflections 5500 are probably on par with one another in my opinion at the top, then the Vinylmax Edison and Ply Gem Premium are on par with one another in the sort of middle.
Then the ViWinco Cambridge and 4700 series are on the bottom.
Basically, the Vinylmax Newton or Reflections 5500 would be my choice in this battle of window series :)
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
Ply Gem Windows vs Simonton
Dane, it's come down to these windows specifically, and I'm having a hard time comparing specs. Maybe you can help. I'm leaning toward Plygem in part because they offer their patio slider in premium as well, and it is one of few sliders that earned the most efficient award from Energy Star. Simonton Inovo seems to also be a good door, but it didn't make the ES list. (Maybe it can be modified?)
Anyway, things I like about Simonton 6500 windows is that they come with lo-e (not 366) coatings, supercept spacer, and 7/8 inch argon filled glass.
Simonton 5500 has intercept spacer and 3/4 inch argon filled glass, but you can opt for 1 inch glass and supercept and lo-e 366 (I'm not sure how much it is for the upgrade).
Meanwhile, I can't seem to find specs for the Plygem premium or what their upgrade options might be, if certain things arent standard. Based on that the Simonton 6500 has the things I want (apart from the coil balance which I don't really want, and also I have questions about the warranty, and have concerns about having it installed by HD) I wanted to get more info if possible please from your perspective.
Ideally I'd like windows to have at least the 7/8 or 1" glass, lo-e coating of any kind (don't care if it's 366 or not), supercept/stainless spacer at a minimum, DP ratings of 40-50, block and tackle balances, high energy efficiency (both Simonton 5500/6500 and Plygem premium earned the Energy Star top honors, but only the Plygem patio door made the list, as well).
I'm not considering any other brands or series, just only these ones I've mentioned. I want to give Plygem a fair shake but am finding their information more limited. Also I am unsure about upgrading the Simonton 5500 vs just going with the 6500 based on cost.
JP- Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
JP, I think you're getting caught up in the nuances here -- in my opinion the Ply Gem Premium and the Simonton 6500 series (very similar to the 5500 series as far as I'm concerned) are pretty darn equal windows. Are there some basic differences, yes, but overall these windows are going to perform very similarly.
If this were my project, I would compare the installers and make my judgement based on how well they are reviewed/rated online. This is going to be the much more important factor going forward. I agree with you on HD installation -- it's too hit or miss for me. Therefore, I'd go with the Ply Gem option if the installation company has a solid track record.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2032
PlyGem Premium vs. Simonton 5500
Thank you for your website...it has been an incredible resource in this complex world of replacement windows!! We are replacing 15 windows in an older home located in Pleasantville NY (which I recently inherited)...12 replacements and 3 new construction (including 2 casements). We have a contractor who will install the windows (amongst other things he is doing for us)...we are trying to keep the costs down but trying to ensure the windows look nice and we do not lose the old home charm...not sure if we are keeping the home (for our son), renting it or selling it yet...so with that said we are trying to decide on several brands with a wide range of pricing (and quality)--please note I have had trouble locating a soft-lite and sunrise dealer near me which is unfortunate...as both those brands interest me...
I am trying to get an Ideal quote as well (but not sure what lines the vendor carries and they seem reluctant to provide a quote -- these are the Anderson and Marvin vendor called Jilco) -- all windows are double hung except for two casements in the kitchen...we are looking for the divided lites inside for the top window only and white exterior /interior ... hardware white, 1/2 screens on all windows (except Marvin and Anderson)...tried to stay with similar series windows as well to keep comparisons easier... would like your advice on the following quotes before tax (please note these quotes are for windows only - delivery on most seems to be around 6 weeks -- the Marvin dealer indicated they could be ~20 weeks):
Key Contenders:
Anderson 400 - Dual Pane Low-E4 Standard Argon Fill Finelight Grilles-Between-the-Glass, Full Screen $13,649
Marvin Elevate Series Low E2 w/Argon, Grills btw Glass, Full Screen $12,039
Starmark (waiting on quote)
Provia Endure 601 ComforTech DLA-UV Double Glass (with Fineline) $7,074
Provia Endure 601 ComforTech DLA-UV HC Double Glass (w/o Fineline) $6,135
OKNA Insul-Tec 500 series Heatseal Deluxe / 700 series for casements $6,029
OKNA Envirostar 800 series Heatseal Deluxe / 700 series for casements $7,259.80
PlyGem Premium $5,200 (est - waiting on full quote)
Other Quotes Received so far but likely off the list:
Kas-Kel Ecoshield $3,970
Simonton 5500 $7,300 (est)
PlyGem Pro $4,900 (est)
Jeld-wen Builders Vinyl $6,212
Jeld-wen 2500 series $16,935
The OKNA and Provia windows are where I am leaning right now (given the cost of Anderson and Marvin) and have an interest in the PlyGem premium window but not sure if they are at the same level of the other two brands...If you could let me know your thoughts and if I should keep pursuing other brands or do you think I have a good pool to choose from?
Thank you for your assistance and once again thank you for your website...this is very helpful...
Bob - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Hey Bob, thanks for the email. I whole heartedly agree with you on your "top 2" -- The fact that the Okna 500 series is the cheapest bid is incredible as they are one of the best windows on that list. The ProVia Endure is an excellent window as well, but I would probably put the Okna 500 above it myself -- not by much...Ply Gem makes an okay window, but they can't touch Okna or ProVia in my opinion.
For me, I would shift my focus from the product to who is doing the work. You have essentially two great bids there and now it's time to determine which company has the best ratings/reviews and will serve you best. Look up the companies and aggregate their ratings from Google, Yelp, HomeAdvisor, Angi, etc. That should give you a pretty clear picture of the quality you can expect. The windows are 50% of the equation and the company doing the work is the other 50%.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Ply Gem Premium In Houston, Texas
Hello, we are looking for a mid range Ply-gem window, or any other manufacture that you can recommend. We live in Houston, Texas so need something that can handle both the heat and humidity. Appreciate any input.
Sandra - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Sandra, here is my list.
The PlyGem Pro and Premium.
The Simonton Reflections 5500 and Impressions 9800.
The Don Young 8900 aluminum window.
The NT Executive series.
The Milgard Hermosa or Milgard aluminum series.
These should get you all started!
Tim - Site Editor - from 2019
Ply Gem Premium vs. Revere Berkshire Elite
Hello Dane, would you compare the Revere Berkshire and the Plygem Premium. Also, do you think triple pane windows is a game changer? I appreciate your help in this matter.
Manita - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Hi Manita, the Revere Berkshire Elite is a very solid mid range vinyl window. The Plygem Premium is a very solid mid range vinyl window. I'd put them on par with one another. In these cases, I always advise comparing the installation companies instead of the windows. Triple pane is a nice feature, but not always super necessary. I'd say if you live in a climate that is extreme, the triple pane is something to look at.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2019
Ply Gem Premium vs. Slocomb Heritage Series
Hi Dane, I'm replacing 14 windows with vinyl casements. The area i'm in doesn't have many decent manufacturers to choose from. I've been quoted $7944 for mi windows but having read what your site has to say about them I'm reluctant to go with that. The same company has access to ply gen and I've requested a bid on them. Another smaller company, possibly a one man operation, offers Slocomb windows. What would be your recommendation?
Thanks in advance.
Jim - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Jim, MI, Ply Gem and Slocomb are all relatively similar in the quality of their windows. I would rank them Slocomb, PlyGem and MI. However, the MI Energy Core vinyl window (MIs premium series) is a much better window than the Slocomb Heritage Series (their entry level window). I'd stick to MI's premium window or PlyGem and Slomcomb's mid range or premium series myself. I think these will offer quality and value. Make sure the company doing the install is reputable and stands behind their work.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2019
Ply Gem Premium For Noise Reduction
Hi, thank you for your site, I have done a lot of reading and learned quite a bit.
One issue I have not been able to uncover is what make/model spec window is a budget friendly option that is best at reducing roadway noise?
The busy intersection by our home in Katy, TX is plagued with jake brake and muffler noise all hours of the night. I have read that laminated glass is a good option but it is too expensive for the 15 windows we need to replace.
Your suggestions for budget friendly noise-reducing make/model or specs is greatly appreciated.
Thank you.
Eddie - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Eddie, so noise reduction windows tend to be pretty pricey, so its tough to give budget friendly recommendations. A couple of points here to note: good quality double pane windows will do quite a bit to reduce the noise when compared with old aluminum single pane windows. However, windows can reduce noise into the house but if your walls aren't well insulated, noise gets through here as well so this might only get you so far.
The biggest sound deadener is the glass. Laminated glass does kill sound but the space between the panes of glass will do the most to kill sound. The more space, the better.
Some people put inserts on the exterior of their windows that sort of artificially creates that big space between the windows. Indoor of Portland Oregon makes a noise reduction window. There are a number of other insert options that you might want to take a look at to at least get some pricing for and some free bids.
The Amsco Serenity series is a relatively budget friendly option that may or may not be available in your area.
I think the bottom line is to get more information on your house and get some opinions from local companies who may shed some light on the best options for your house. It's always kind of a balancing act between the cost and how much noise reduction you need.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2019
[Eddie's Reply]
Tim, thanks so much for your time and feedback. Most of what you share coincides with the research I’ve done as well.
I was quoted the Serenity window by Amsco. Houston Window Experts quoted me over $7,000 per window for two windows. I wasn’t even shocked I actually just laughed at the salesperson.
We currently have 17 year old builder grade aluminum double pane windows. Seal is so bad you can feel the temperature outside within 2 feet of the interior of the window.
Research and availability has me leaning toward the Ply Gem Premium Casement window, triple pane, with their best glass package. I’m waiting on a quote for that product installed.
If the new windows do their part and the walls become the weak link, my research has lead me to considering drywall stacking with a layer of something called Green Glue. Seems to be the least expensive way to take care of noise through walls.
Thanks again.
Eddie - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
That quote from Amsco is ridiculous. I would think the Ply Gem triple pane option would be a very good upgrade to what you have. It would a significant improvement and about all you can do short of going with a full noise reduction window. Assuming the price is right, I would go with that option.
Let me know how the project goes!
Tim - Site Editor - from 2019
Ply Gem Premium Quality
Hi Tim, we replaced 9 windows in our previous house with CertainTeed with great results and were quite happy. With our new house (new for us, built in 2005) we are again looking to replace with high-efficiency windows. The new house is more complicated, much bigger, with large chalet style walls/windows (e.g. one wall has 6 lower windows, and 6 upper, angled windows).
Given that PlyGem replaced CertainTeed, we are looking at those for replacement options. However, in your review you said ‘Ply Gem windows aren't going to the best in the business’ and mentioned they were more for new-builds (though that was for the Contractor series). We want this to be a good purchase with high-end results as this would be a close to final house for us, and we live in a cold state.
Do you have any recommendations on other brands we should research? We live in Anchorage, Alaska.
Chris - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Answer]
Chris, I stand by the statement that Ply Gem aren't the best in the business, but they aren't bad by any means. Their Premium series is a good vinyl window and one that I would have in my own home. Ask about any upgrades that might be available, such as frame fills for increased rigidity, insulation and performance. Make sure that the installer of the Ply Gem windows has a good track record, online reviews and BBB standing.
As to other window brands in your area, I can't say that I know offhand. Google "milgard windows in anchorage alaksa" for instance and see if any dealers come up. Do this for Milgard, Anlin, Amerimax, Simonton, and Marvin. This should give you a pretty good idea of who sells in your area.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2017
Ply Gem Windows vs Paradigm 8300 Series
Hello, we are currently getting approximately 15 double hungs plus a picture window in our home here in Michigan. The company we are working with has several choices, however, we are making a huge investment and need help! ( unbiased!)
PlyGem
Andersen Silver line
Paradigm
I did some digging on silver line and am not satisfied with the quality and even how they handled customers. If you have any suggestions, would appreciate the input as we are at a deadline...
Thank you in advance!
Laurie - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Answer]
Laurie, you are right to dismiss Silverline, their windows are basically junk. The 9500 series with a couple of upgrades is not bad though. However, you can and should do better. The Ply Gem Pro or Ply Gem Premium are both solid mid range vinyl windows. I like the Premium model over the Pro and it should be more than 10% to 20% more for the upgrade.
I would go with the upgraded Paradigm 8300 series I think as well. It has some nice components and decent numbers. I think with the upgraded glass package and good installation, you would be well served with this window. I like the upgrades of the 8300 series over the Paradigm 5000 series. Paradigm Windows Reviews
Bottom line is this -- both Ply Gem and Paradigm are known as solid mid range vinyl window manufacturers. If you go with their premium series, you are getting a mid-to-upper-end mid range vinyl window, which should serve you well.
One more solid mid range manufacturer in your state is Wallside windows. You may want to get a bid from them just to see how their price points compare to Ply Gem and Paradigm.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2017
Plygem vs Soft-Lite Imperial LS
I’m trying to evaluate some of the major brands available in the Kansas City area by their NFRC data on U-Factor and SHGC. I was surprised when I rank ordered data on PlyGem PremiumEP, Soft-Lite Imperial LS and Elements, and Okna 500 and 800, that the Plygem Premium has significantly better U and SHGC ratings than any of the other brands.
Given that Plygem is considered a mid-grade vinyl window and the others are Tier 1, how can this be explained? Should I really be considering a Plygem Premium over these other brands?
I don’t have pricing on any of them yet, that’s coming next week.
In trying to find a quality local installer that could obtain OKNA windows in Kansas City (no dealers locally), I found one that has very high install ratings, but installs solely Plygem. He is willing to look into obtaining Okna product, but is very high on Plygem. Is Plygem really better than your reviews might lead one to believe relative to Okna, Soft-Lite, Sunrise? Or should I really exclude Plygem from my serious consideration and only look at this installer for any Okna opportunities?
Bob - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Answer]
Bob, thanks for the question, it is an EXCELLENT one. The nfrc data is difficult to wade through and can be confusing because there are so many ways to slice and dice the numbers. For instance, the Ply Gem Premium window with clear glass gets a .39 U-value, with the HP 2 gets .27, with the Max glass gets down to a .25, and the HP 3 delivers a .22. All based on glass, but no changes to the window frame itself. I try to always compare windows with a basic low-e glass and grids as a way to do an apples-to-apples comparison, but even then sometimes that comparisons are a bit off.
SHGC is the amount of solar heat that is allowed through the window, so this is more a function of your location (you want a higher shgc in cold locations and less shgc in warm climates) and also the direction the window faces -- both places where a good contractor or window company should be able to help you out.
Vinyl windows are tricky because they often look the same and, as you noted, the NFRC values can be very similar depending on the glass packages. Where the differences lie is with the the manufacturing tolerances, the rigidity and overall strength of the extrusion, as well as the long term manufacturer's reliability.
Ultimately, I think the best performance number to compare is air infiltration or air leakage. The Ply Gem Premium is a good window, but I believe their air infiltration is something like .08 to .12 (I may be a bit off, if you know the exact number do let me know). The Soft-Lite Imperial LS is .02 and the Elements is .01, the Okna 500 is .02 and the 800 is .01. I typically say .10 or lower is good, .05 or lower is great.
The bottom line is that the Ply Gem Premium is a good window and I like the fact that the local installer has a good history with the window, installs it a lot, knows who to contact if their are issues etc. I still think that most industry experts would rate the high end series of Soft-Lite and Okna above the Ply Gem Premium and I feel that the AI number bears witness to that. Quality of the installer though has to play an important role in your decision as well.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2017
Ply Gem Windows vs Window World 4000
I am trying to decide between PlyGem Premium Series and Window World 4000 Mezzo. I will have both casements and sliders. Which window is better?
Barb - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Answer]
Barb, the Ply Gem premium is the better window between these two. The Window World Alside Mezzo is not a bad window per se, but the Ply Gem Premium is I would say a better built and stronger window overall.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2016
Ply Gem Windows vs Anderson 400 Series
Is the Andersen 400 Series or PlyGem Premium series a better bet?
Corey - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Response]
Corey, the Ply Gem Premium is vinyl and the Andersen 400 is a wood window with an aluminum clad wood exterior. The Andersen 400 series is a good wood window, but wood clad windows are more expensive than vinyl and require you to protect the wood periodically by painting or staining the wood. Most homeowners don't want to be bothered with this hassle. Also performance wise, the Ply Gem Premium is going to be much better. If you are really adamant about wood, then go with the Andersen, but if not, go with the Ply Gem Premium model.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2016
Ply Gem Windows vs Wallside
I'm looking to replace 18 windows in MI. I'm looking at a Ply Gem Premium series window or a Wallside. Which do you think would be a better window to go with? Wallside Windows reviews
[Site Editor's Response]
Tom, I would have to say that the Ply Gem premium window is going to be a better option than the Wallside option. Wallside manufactures their own vinyl windows and I would say that it's just an OK midrange vinyl window, depending on the number of features and upgrades that you go with. Wallside, to the best my knowledge, does do their own installation which I really like because their installation teams only deal with their windows and therefore havea pretty deep understanding of the intricacies and issues with that particular install. I guess I would ask how comfortable you are with whoever is doing the install on the Ply Gem Windows, this could be the difference.
The Ply Gem premium window would offer better performance numbers, offer a more durable construction and should carry a better warranty then the wall side.
Incidentally, how was your experience with the wall side bid process, I have heard that they go in for the hard sell and was just curious what your overall impressions were?
Dane - Site Editor - from 2015
Ply Gem HPMAX Triple Pane Windows
We are in bay area in California. Plygem is offering triple pane hpmax3 200, 700 and 960 windows for my house. They are offering as good a price as a dual pane window from Marvin. What is your opinion on these windows. I would appreciate your help here
Gobi - Homeowner - from 2015
[Editor's Response]
Gobi, the big question is which model are being offered for the HPMAX from Ply Gem? Contractor, Pro or Premium? Also which model from Marvin? Integrity, Infinity or Ultimate? I would say that the Ply Gem Premium is probably on par with Marvin Integrity window prices.
In general, I would say that PlyGem is considered something of a 2nd tier vinyl replacement window manufacturer, while Marvin is considered a first tier fiberglass and wood clad replacement window company. So on the face of it, I would have to say go with the Marvin. Northern California has a relatively mild climate (compared with much of the country) and I'm not sure you even need a triple pane window. I would almost prefer a good dual pane window because there are less parts/piece to fail.
This is my 2 cents.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2015
Ply Gem Premium vs Soft-Lite Bainbridge
I need to replace 10 windows in a rental. I honestly want something cheap, not total garbage but I just need to fill the holes. I'm in Milwaukee. What brands should I look at?
Bruce - Homeowner - from 2010
[Contractor Response]
>Softlite has a dealer there, but it's going to be over your budget I think. Simontons would probably work, too, but I'd look at PlyGem. Their Premium series is a decent window for a pretty good price. It isn't an exciting window, but it works pretty well. The PlyGem Pro is probably even better for you - good enough quality and very low price.
Harry - Contractor - from 2010
Ply Gem Premium Series vs Simonton Windows
I'm in Oklahoma where we have crazy weather patterns. We need to replace windows and I can't decide between a Premium Reliabilt, Premium Simonton or Plygem Premium Series.
CC - Homeowner - from 2010
[Contractor Response]
Simonton and PlyGem in that order would be my pick. The Reliabilt tends to be a tier below in terms of quality and craftsmanship. When it come to the question of Ply Gem Pro vs Premium window series, I say you gotta go premium.
Harry - Contractor - 2010
Ply Gem Windows vs Great Lakes 5000 Series
Allied Building Products has a private label window called "Cutting Edge" and I'm trying to figure out who manufactures it. Any ideas?
Jay - Homeowner from 2010
[Contractor Response]
They're made by MI. They are also sometimes called Xacts. They are a cheap, builder grade window designed to be the lowest cost possible. If you have your heart set on Allied, look at the PlyGem Premium or Great Lakes 5000 series. Before you buy anything take the time to check out Okna, Gorell, Sunrise, Polaris, and SoftLite. With any of those, you'll be getting a window that's worth your money and won't fall apart in five years. Xact Windows Reviews
Holland - Contractor - from 2010
Ply Gem Windows Reviews :: 200 Series
Ply Gem Pro 200 Questions
Aren't the Ply Gem Pro 200 the Pro series, or is that different?
And would you recommend the Tuscany (or another Milgard series) over the StyleLine?
The Milgard Tuscany that you said was fairly good has a wide frame that takes up more of your viewing area.
Would you say the Plygem Premium would be equal to the Milgard Styleline?
Or what Plygem series would be better than Styleline, but still have a thin frame?
Does plygem 200 have a thin frame?
Doug - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Doug, I know the 200 and 400 used the same frame, but the 400 has several nice upgrades and custom options available. In general, a mid range window.
The Milgard Tuscany is a better mid range vinyl window. The frame is a bit bulkier, certainly bulkier than the Style Line. Any thin frame window you get that aims to maximize glass area will have worse energy efficiency and strength. That's the bargain you are striking.
Put the following search into google for some more opinions on Ply Gem 200.
site:www.replacement-windows.com ply gem 200
Tim - Site Editor - from 2020
Ply Gem 200 Double Hung Price Quote
I was told by the lumber place that when they do the cutout way, they are not screwing the window on the install flanges, but diagonally into the wood framing, and that this can cause warping.
For the windows that already have trim, doing the full frame install would be pretty simple, it's just the windows that have siding up to the window.
Was looking at Ply Gem, there are made locally here, but for their Google Reviews are 3 out of 5, a lot of people say they can't get their problems fixed under the warranty.
So would you say for windows that already have trim boards around them that a full frame install would be $100 more than a cutout install, since all they have to do is remove the trim, install window, and then replace the trim boards? So would that be maybe $600 per window?
And for windows where they have to cut the siding out, those would be around $700?
By HD, do you mean Simonton Daylight?
Are the Ply Gem Pro Series 200 good quality?
Johnny - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
The lumber place is correct abt the installation method. Buying a quality window however means they won't have warping issues that a low quality window could have.
Ply Gem is big company and I'm not surprised about the warranty issues. You want to find a well reputed dealer who is going to handle any warranty issues themselves. That's why finding a quality installer who has been around for a while is so important. Trying to go directly to the company about warranty issues can be a nightmare.
I can't say exactly how much the full frame replacement will run, but the numbers you mentioned sound like they are in the ballpark of what you can expect.
"By HD, do you mean Simonton Daylight?" Yes, that is correct.
The Ply Gem 200 is their lower end double hung. I think I'd stick with their 300 or 400 double hung.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2020
Ply Gem 200 vs Milgard Styleline
We're replacing 22 windows in our Oregon home and want a good, but not great, vinyl window. Milgard Style Line is an option, as well Ply Gem 200 series. Would you have an opinion of one over the other?
Tory - Homeowner - from 2018
[Website Editor Reply]
Tory, the Milgard Styleline and Ply Gem 200 Pro are pretty good options and quite similar in performance, price and quality. I would give the nod to the Ply Gem Pro over the Style Line.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2018
Plygem 200 Series vs. Amsco Studio Series
Hello, I will keep this short. First time ever shopping to replace 3 bedroom windows (one expensive one with the arch on top). Looking for a decent quality and price.
Between Amsco studio series and plygem 200 series which one would be better, they are the same price. $2300 installed.
Can't quite splurge for milguard Tuscany series quoted at $3500 I live in Arizona. Thank you!
Nataliya - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Answer]
Nataliya, the Amsco is a cheaply made window. The Ply Gem 200 is the better of the two. This is the one I would go with if the price is the same.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2017
Ply Gem Windows Reviews :: 400 Series
Ply Gem 410 Series vs. Anlin Del Mar
Dane, I am interested in your list of bear windows / installers in Houston.
15 to 20 windows for replacement.
Have original single pane aluminum. No problems just not energy efficient. 4500 ft2 home and annual utility bills (gas and electric) are around $3200 total. Have done a lot with ac and attic insulation.
Looking at aluminum. Looked first at many vinyl (Anlin Del Mar e, Amsco Restoration, Anderson, Pella, Simonton). Was not impressed with interior of any and vinyl finish / seems were not great.
Looking at NT, Don Young and also a Ply Gem 410 with the HPsc glass selection.
Also not interested in the tilt function and only single hung. Most windows are typical medium size (36x60 inch type) but I have two very large front windows with round tops.
Any thoughts on best options? Is Ply Gem 410 aluminum a window you would avoid.
16 windows - two large windows but a good deal of average and 4 small to very small windows. Anlin delmar e. Installed $36k. I loved the exterior, but the interior did not look good. I would not have installed rhem regardless of price.
William - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Hi Howard, here are my Texas recommendations and I added my two aluminum windows that I really like…
[Email dane@replacementwindowsreviews.co for his recommendations]
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Ply Gem 400 Windows Reviews
Dane, I am replacing 33 windows in my home and I am in the process of getting 4 estimates. One company has suggested to use a sash replacement kit with a Plygem 400 series window vs. replacing the whole window unit with a window such as the Simonton Assure or 5500 series.
My window sills and exterior molding are in very good shape. The company recommending the sash kit route has an excellent install reputation. Per the installer, the advantage of using the sash only kit is the cost would be less and it would not reduce my "total glass area" as would be the case with using the Simonton Assure or 5500 units. I would appreciate your recommendation on the sash only vs. replacement option.
Thank you.
Brent - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Brent, in general the sash kit is a viable option if your existing frames/sills are in good shape. I always suggest getting a few bids in these scenarios for no other reason than it's good to get multiple professional opinions as to the quality of your frames (and whether they think sill kit replacement is a viable option).
Assuming they agree that sash kits are the way to go, then go for it. You save glass area and you save money.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2019
Ply Gem Windows Reviews :: 5100 Series
Hi Dane, I got two quotes, one from Window World Series 4000 HD they quoted $5445 - 5 double hungs , 1 picture window, 1 2 liter slider. The other one from home depot using a PlyGem 5100 window $6446. Question: Is the PlyGem 5100 better than the WW Series 4000? The plygem looks alot more solid than the 4000.
Prasanth - Homeowner - from 2023
[Site Editor's Answer]
Prasanth, the PlyGem 5100 series is the much better window in my opinion over the Window World 4000 series. It's a solid window -- the price is toward the top of what I'd like to see though -- how many bids have you collected thus far?
Dane - Site Editor - from 2023
Ply Gem Windows Reviews :: 6000 Series
Ply Gem 6000 Series vs. Zen Nirvana
I currently have 3 quotes for windows.
Ply gem 6000 series $8400
Zen Nirvana $9200
Vi Win Tech 6000 $7100
What is the best window out of the three?
Thanks.
Vincent - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Answer]
Vincent, I think the bid prices reflect the quality almost to a tee. The Zen Nirvana is the best of the bunch, then the Ply Gem 6000, and then the ViWinTech at the bottom. How many windows is this for?
I would try and go with the Zen Nirvana if you can as this is a good window. However, there is nothing stopping you from leveraging the lower prices of the other bids to see if you can drive down the bid price from the Zen dealer. Here is an article that suggests an approach to do just this.
https://www.replacementwindowsreviews.co/review-topics/negotiating-a-home-window-bid.html
Dane - Site Editor - from 2017
[Vincent's Reply]
Dane, thank you for your response. This is for 17 windows. What about Pella Therma Star windows? I received a quote today that is for about $6500 for those. Are they a good window?
Vincent - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Answer]
Vincent, that's a decent price for the Ply Gem and Zen, but definitely not on the low end of what I've seen. I would see what I could do to work them down in price.
The Pella ThermaStar is an awful window and you should not put that in your home. It is consistently rated one of the worst windows by consumer reports (and CR only tests retail windows, which is a low bar to begin with).
Dane - Site Editor - from 2017
[Vincent's Reply]
Dane, thank you so much for your help. I was able to get the plygem down to $7400, which includes lead safe practices for 17 windows. The Zen window dealer is still at $9200 with lead safe practices. So he went down some but the lead paint brought it back up. I’m thinking of going with the plygem as it’s more in budget. Do you think that’s a good quality window or should I pay more for the Zen? Thanks.
Vincent - Homeowner - from 2017
[Site Editor's Answer]
I think at $7400, the Ply Gem probably becomes the best deal, but still not necessarily the best window. I would say this -- if you get good and thorough installation on the Ply Gem 6000 window, I think you should be just fine. Just make sure that the company has a good reputation and will be around to address any concerns that may come up in the future.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2017
Ply Gem Windows Reviews :: 9000 Series
PlyGem 9000 Series vs. Sunrise
Dane, thank you for the list of windows to start researching my project. I've had 2 companies come out so far and I'm waiting on estimates to come in. The first company is using PGT 5400 window line. The second company is quoting me two windows the Simonton/PlyGem 9000 series and the other is the Provia Endure series. I was really interested in the Sunrise windows either the Restorations or Vanguard line but the company that is an authorized dealer for Sunrise says that the Sunrise windows won't meet the local DP rating requirements of 50 DP.
I can't find any information about local requirements for DP and I was wondering if you might know anything about the Sunrise rating. I'm located in coastal North Carolina in Sunset Beach. I'm on the mainland side of Sunset Beach about a mile from the intercoastal waterway. I have checked with all of the top tier recommendations and most don't have a dealer in my area. I appreciated any insights you may have.
Thank you.
Rob - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Rob, I don't know what the DP rating is on the sunrise. This is what I have on the Sunrise Restorations, but no DP rating. The Sunrise Restorations, with the Cold Protector Extreme AR glass package, should deliver a 0.22 U-factor, 0.19, .04 air infiltration, and 0.44 VT. Upgrading to the Ultra KR90 glass package will deliver a 0.19 U-factor, 0.20, .03 air infiltration, and 0.37 VT.
However, the company sells a hurricane rated window with a DP rating of 70. https://www.sunrisewindows.com/blog/product-of-the-month-sunrise-coastal-windows/ I'd call the Sunrise dealer and ask if he has access to this window.
I do like the PGT 5400 series window.
I REALLY like the ProVia Endure window. The Endure is better in my opinion, than the Sunrise standard, and almost on par with the Restorations series.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Ply Gem 9000 vs. Alside Mezzo
Hi Tim, can you please compare these two windows. We are looking to have 25 windows installed and we want to make sure we are getting a good deal. We hav gotten quotes on the Plygem 9000 series—was told this is their top of the line window and a quote on Alside Messo. Thank you in advance.
Renee - Homeowner - from 2019
[Site Editor's Answer]
Renee, the Ply Gem 9000 is a solid vinyl window, as is the Alside Mezzo. I would give the edge to the Ply Gem 9000 model, better made and sturdier in my opinion. Assuming these two windows are comparable in price, the Ply Gem is where I would put my money.
Two pretty solid choices. Let me know what you decide!
Tim - Site Editor - from 2019
General Ply Gem Windows Reviews
Ply Gem Windows vs. Okna
Hi Dane, thank you for all the information on your site. I wish I would have come across it before we purchased 19 Ply gem windows for our home 1.5 years ago. I recently gave up on trying to get a resolution for the air blowing in along the frame at the corners where the upper and lower sash meet. The manufacturer's service tech, contractor nor the supplier can figure it out and no one is returning my calls now so I am to the point where I'm researching new windows, and these will be returned.
Your site has been invaluable in helping me sort through all the options and I believe it has come down to what appears to be some of the top options. I'm looking at SoftLite, Okna and Sunrise. I believe we have SoftLite and Sunrise available in our area, near Grand Rapids, MI, and I've sent a request to Okna to see if they have a dealer near me.
Which of these manufacturers and series of each would you recommend for an energy efficient window in a home we plan to stay in for many years? Bonus for throwing in highly rated installers near me!
We need to purchase:
17 double hung (8 with dark woodgrain interior)
2 sliders
1 Octagon or Awning if opening octagon isn't available
Thanks so much!
Linda - Homeowner - from 2022
[Website Editor Reply]
Linda, here are my recommendations:
[Email dane@replacementwindowsreviews.co for his recommendations]
Dane - Website Editor - from 2022
Ply Gem Storm Windows
Dane, I'm thinking of replacing my windows but it's a maze out there. I'm looking at the ply gem storm window with a DP 50 rating since I live close to the coast. How do I find out if the ply gem storm window is a exterior installation. Secondly what...
Pedro - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Pedro, I'm not quite sure what you mean by an exterior installation. Retrofit windows are installed by cutting out the existing window and are positioned in the frame. New construction is more complex and involves removing the window down to the frame. The new window is installed from the outside using the nailing fin along the top and sides. Your second question was cut off.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2020
Ply Gem Builder Contractor Series 400
Good afternoon. I have a 1950’s brick home and would like to do replacement windows.
This is a rental that I plan on keeping long term so I am trying to help our tenants (7 years with us) lower their cooling in the Arizona summers and help modernize it for future tenants.
I have had 2 companies bid and getting ready for the 3rd. All highly rated installers and comparable prices.
So it comes down to the actual window- which one would you recommend
Ply Gem builder contractor series 400
MI professional 5000-5800
The 3rd company says they use AMI (associated material ?) but I don’t know which level- assuming lowest since it is a rental.
If you had to choose from these 3- which would you choose?
Thank you so much for your time
Toni - Homeowner - from 2020
[Website Editor Reply]
Toni, these aren’t the best window options, but they are probably fine for a rental. I think I would say the MI Professional over the Ply Gem Contractor series. These would be my number one and number two.
So I think the bigger issue would be to find the better installation company. This will be the bigger factor in the longevity of the window and their effectiveness. Check for online reviews and reputation and choose the best installer.
Dane - Website Editor - from 2020
Ply Gem And M&W Windows
Hello, Did ply gem take over M&w windows? have a question on how to open top window. windows are 18 y.r. old
Lee - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Answer]
Lee, yes M&W windows was bought out by Ply Gem back in 2004.
Check out this video for an overall tutorial -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qOrDAR-ne7M
Look in the right hand of your monitor for related videos that might be applicable to fixing your old windows. You can also find a local window repairman and pay them for an hour of their time to come out and help you get your old windows working again.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2016
Ply Gem Or MI Windows
We are in the process of renovating a 1950s mid century modern house in Houston, TX. Our builder has given us the option of Ply Gem or MI windows. Can you tell me which would be better? Thanks!
Katherine - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Answer]
Katherine, Ply Gem is clearly the better of those two window brands. Frankly, MI is a builder grade window that is not particularly made well in terms of long term durability. I would avoid the Ply Gem Contractor and would insist on either the Ply Gem Pro or better yet the Premium Ply Gem vinyl window. It's quite good.
Dane - Site Editor - from 2016
Ply Gem Windows Warranty Claim
I have a Certainteed sliding patio door that is fogging up and leaking between the panes. Now that PlyGem is taking care of Warranties for Certaineed I cannot find anyone to help me. I have called 888-975-9436 three days in a row. They connect me to someone's voice mail to leave a message, but no one contacts me. How should I proceed?? I live in southern California. Thanks.
Michelle - Homeowner - from 2016
[Site Editor's Response]
Michelle, my advise would be to find a Ply Gem rep in your area or contact the company directly. You could always try to contact them through the website, but I think it's doubtful whether they will get back to you.
Unfortunately, these issues can be frustrating to deal with unless you have the contact info of whomever helped you originally.
I will post your issue online and hopefully you can find a local rep who can give you more specifics on the warranty claim.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2016
PlyGem Windows vs Wallside
I have had reps from both Ply Gem and Wallside, read reviews on line and talked to past customers who have Wallside windows. Prices, quality, "u" ratings seem very similar. Tough decision. Anything else I should consider?
Robert - Homeowner - from 2015
[Site Editor's Response]
Robert, I would agree with you that Wallside and PlyGem are very similar in price and quality. If we assume that the window replacement equation is 50% window and 50% installation, I'd say it's now time to compare the companies and the installation team that will be doing the work. Have you compared
Company Reviews?
Customer Referals?
Yelp, Google and BBB ratings?
Labor (Installation) Warranties?
How they handle misorders?
How they handle customer dissatisfaction?
Finally, what does your gut tell you? This one isn't very scientific, but it is often one of the best ways to decide between two very evenly matched companies.
Tim - Site Editor - from 2015
Ply Gem Seabrooke Review
We are thinking about replacing our windows and are looking at Great Lakes Seabrooks installed by Windows Doors and More from Ft Wayne IN. We want windows that will last and improve our home. Would these be a good choice?
Sally - Homeowner - from 2015
[Editor's Response]
Sally, the Seabrooke is made by Great Lakes and is not a bad vinyl window, although it is their less expensive model (I usually recommend trying to stretch into the mid range series). The Uniframe is certainly a good vinyl window -- have you gotten window pricing on either this or the Lifestyles (mid range), just to see how they compare?
One rule of thumb I might throw out is to go with a better model or series and then see how to get the per window cost down from there. One place is in the components such as going with a plastic hardware instead of the upgraded metal or upgraded color frame. Ask the sales person to suggest places to reduce the cost, without sacrificing quality (you will sometimes sacrifice on aesthetics, but I've found that once vinyl windows are installed you barely notice them unless they leak or do not work properly).
I don't know the company you mentioned for the installation, but the installation is half the equation, so getting really thorough installation is a very important component. How are their reviews? Get some references just to make sure that you like what you hear from other consumers on their services etc. Great Lakes has a good reputation (they are owned by Ply Gem) and make a solid vinyl window. Let me know how it goes!
Pete - Industry Expert - from 2015
Ply Gem Windows Complaint
I have replaced all the windows in my house with Ply Gem replacement windows. A large bay window in the front of the house leaked the day it was installed. They sent a service tech to fix it and he said it needs to be replaced . It has now been a year and no new window. The warranty people do not return calls and when I get them on the line they just say we will take care of it. Now I have another one of the new windows that has moisture between the pains of glass. Bay Windows Prices
Jonah - Homeowner - from 2014
PlyGem Windows vs Pella
I have two quotes for six slider windows. The Ply Gem Lifestyles (local installer), or the Pella 20 Series (Lowes installation). The price is roughly equal.
Jack - Homeowner - from 2012
[Contractor Response]
The Plygem Lifestyles window is the better of the two. These aren't the best windows out there by any means, but the Ply Gem is a decent enough option.
Kendall - Contractor - from 2012
Ply Gem Vinyl Windows Review
Plygem is a good mid-grade window. You sometimes find someone trying to sell it as a premium, but if you do the research you can get a good price. I would get the energy package, you get reinforced sashes, foam filled frames, and a stainless steel spacer. They're a little more expensive but it's worth it.
Harry - Contractor - from 2012
Ply Gem vs Revere
I have estimates for double pane sliders from Revere Windows and triple panes from Plygem. The prices are pretty close. We have awful winters here in North Dakota so I need something that can handle cold. Any feedback on the two?
AJ - Homeowner - from 2010
[Contractor Response]
Plygem is far better that Revere, so if you can get them with an even better glass at around the same price, jump on that. As long as you get a good install they should be great.
Hubert - Contractor - from 2010
Ply Gem Windows Warranty
Plygem is comparable to Great Lakes, Sunrise & Gorell, it all depends on which lines you're looking at. They have a lifetime warranty on glass, and from what I've heard they are pretty good about honoring it without too much hassle. Sometimes I've had them send replacements for stuff that isn't even covered.
Han - Contractor - from 2010
Ply Gem vs Jeld Wen
Plygem vs. Jeld Wen? Which is the better option? I live in Idaho, where there are dry summers and cold winters.
Lisa - Homeowner in Idaho - from 2009
[Contractor Response]
Lisa, the better Ply Gem windows are good. Jeld Wen makes a good door, but a mediocre window.
Manny - Installer - from 2009
Related Topics: Rite Window Reviews
Renewal By Andersen Prices